{"ontologies":{"EUROSCIVOC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.europa.eu/8mn/euroscivoc/40c0f173-baa3-48a3-9fe6-d6e8fb366a00"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://op.europa.eu/s/y4UK","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EUROSCIVOC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"European Science Vocabulary\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"European Science Vocabulary (EuroSciVoc) is the taxonomy of fields of science based on OECD's 2015 Frascati Manual taxonomy. It was extended with fields of science categories extracted from CORDIS content through a semi-automatic process developed with Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"EuroSciVoc","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"016jmhr98\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:016jmhr98\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Publications Office of the European Union\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b9686820-0eba-013c-7f25-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b9686820-0eba-013c-7f25-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"4","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROSCIVOC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"10439"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2021-12-17T03:06:18.000-08:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-10-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://op.europa.eu/en/web/eu-vocabularies/dataset/-/resource?uri=http://publications.europa.eu/resource/dataset/euroscivoc\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"null","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROSCIVOC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROSCIVOC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"null","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"null","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/de, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/es, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/it, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROSCIVOC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROSCIVOC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROSCIVOC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"4"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://op.europa.eu/it/web/eu-vocabularies/controlled-vocabularies, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://op.europa.eu/it/web/eu-vocabularies/controlled-vocabularies, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.europa.eu/8mn/euroscivoc/40c0f173-baa3-48a3-9fe6-d6e8fb366a00","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.europa.eu/8mn/euroscivoc/40c0f173-baa3-48a3-9fe6-d6e8fb366a00"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"null","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":90,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":90.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#taxonomy)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#taxonomy"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"null","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"null","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROSCIVOC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#taxonomy","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"null","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"null","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"null","mod:prefLabelProperty":"null","mod:authorProperty":"null","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":1.0,"normalizedScore":3,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Publications Office of the European Union"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROSCIVOC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.6"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":231.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":772},"MSFDVOCAB":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/msfd/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MSFDVOCAB","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Biodiversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Species_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Marine Strategy Framework Directive vocabulary containing information about the habitats, species groups and marine regions targeted in the European Directive.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Marine Strategy Framework Directive Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MSFDVOCAB/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"70"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/msfd/speciesGroups/\",\"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/msfd/regions/\",\"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/msfd/broadHabitatTypes/\"]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-05-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2014-01-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=MSFDVOCAB&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MSFDVOCAB/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MSFDVOCAB/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MSFDVOCAB/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=MSFDVOCAB&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MSFDVOCAB/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MSFDVOCAB/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MSFDVOCAB","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"3"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://dd.eionet.europa.eu/, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://dd.eionet.europa.eu/, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/msfd/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/msfd/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/msfd/speciesGroups/\",\"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/msfd/regions/\",\"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/msfd/broadHabitatTypes/\"]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MSFDVOCAB/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Biodiversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Species_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"European Environment Agency"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MSFDVOCAB/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":225.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":818},"ENDEMISMS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/endemisms/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":9.0,"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.80186/nbep-6328"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ENDEMISMS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Endemisms Thesaurus\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Thesaurus on endemisms","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Definitions\",\"Endemisms\"]","dct:title":"Endemisms Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"LifeWatch Italy\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lifewatchitaly@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENDEMISMS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"15"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2023-10-21T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2019-05-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://www.lifewatchitaly.eu/web/lifewatch-italia/reports\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ENDEMISMS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENDEMISMS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENDEMISMS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENDEMISMS/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ENDEMISMS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENDEMISMS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENDEMISMS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENDEMISMS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/endemisms/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.80186/nbep-6328"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/endemisms/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENDEMISMS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Stefano De Felici, Fabio Cianferoni]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3170-0774\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3170-0774\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fabio  Cianferoni\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd06db10-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd06db10-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"fabio.cianferoni@unifi.it\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENDEMISMS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1055},"NANO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/np/RAk5g9f95GUYhcpMLMEn5KKh3SsqDHevBT9DXgm6cdlP4"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NANO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Biodiversity\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"this is a test","omv:resourceLocator":"http://np.knowledgepixels.com/RAk5g9f95GUYhcpMLMEn5KKh3SsqDHevBT9DXgm6cdlP4.trig.txt","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"test","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-09-24T08:45:14.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=NANO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=NANO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"3"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/np/RAk5g9f95GUYhcpMLMEn5KKh3SsqDHevBT9DXgm6cdlP4","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/np/RAk5g9f95GUYhcpMLMEn5KKh3SsqDHevBT9DXgm6cdlP4"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Biodiversity\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Martina Pulieri"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0009-0001-9691-1989\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0009-0001-9691-1989\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martina Pulieri\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":227.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1467},"CHEMFONT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://pur.obolibrary.org/obo/Merged.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.chemfont.ca/simple","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CHEMFONT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"ChemFOnt contains data on 341,627 chemicals, including 515,332 terms or definitions. The functional hierarchy for ChemFOnt consists of 4 functional ?aspects?, 12 functional super-categories and a total of 173,705 functional terms. In addition, each of the chemicals are classified into 4,825 structure-based chemical classes. ChemFOnt currently contains 3.9 million protein-chemical relationships and ~10.3 million chemical-functional relationships. The long-term goal for ChemFOnt is for it to be adopted by databases and software tools used by the general chemistry community as well as the metabolomics, exposomics, metagenomics, genomics and proteomics communities.\r\n\r\nAs noted earlier, the 4 functional \"aspects? are divided into 12 function super-categories which are further subdivided into another 399 functional subcategories which are further divided into thousands of other branches or leaf nodes for a maximum depth of up to seven layers. In particular, Physiological Effect has 3,637 defined categories; Disposition has 4,186 defined categories; Process has 161,098 defined categories; and Role has 1,037 defined categories. In total, ChemFOnt has 173,305 fully defined and fully connected functional categories, which are all placed into a logically consistent hierarchy.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Biological molecules\",\"Chemistry\"]","dct:title":"Chemical Functional Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"11864","omv:numberOfProperties":"68","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"chemont","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"184442"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"ChemFOnt (the Chemical Functional Ontology) is a hierarchical, OWL-compatible ontology describing the functions and actions of more than 341,000 biologically important chemicals.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"26","dct:created":"2022-12-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkac919\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=CHEMFONT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"developed by Yannick Djoumbou Feunang & David S. Wishart\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"511","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/CHEMFONT/download","foaf:logo":"https://www.chemfont.ca/assets/ChemFOnt_logo-b605646f327c05d1989b475b16fdf4ec47eb82b139af943942b1f865f1c8190b.png","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=CHEMFONT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"7039","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"259"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":63.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://pur.obolibrary.org/obo/Merged.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://pur.obolibrary.org/obo/Merged.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":" ChemFOnt Project Team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3207-2434\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3207-2434\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"David S. Wishart\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2a8fbf40-9ac6-013d-27bc-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2a8fbf40-9ac6-013d-27bc-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-7850-184X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-7850-184X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yannick Djoumbou Feunang\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0389b9e0-9ac6-013d-27bc-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0389b9e0-9ac6-013d-27bc-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"OBO-Edit 2.3.1\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":527},"PAST":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo-search/cvterms"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"\\tData of past climate and environment derived from unusual proxy evidence. Parameter keywords describe what was measured in this data set. Additional summary information can be found in the abstracts of papers listed in the data set citations.\"]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PAST","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/EARTH\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The World Data Service for Paleoclimatology defines measured variables using the PaST thesaurus of standard terms. These terms describe the quantity measured, the material on which it was measured, reported error, units, analytical or statistical methods, transformations made to raw data, reconstructed seasonality, data type, and data format. Standard terms organize heterogeneous paleoclimate datasets and improve the findability, interoperability, and reusability of data., This file contains concepts, labels, and relationships that make up the Paleoenvironmental Standard Terms (PaST) thesaurus. This representation of the thesaurus follows the Simple Knowledge Organization System (SKOS) data model and has Resource Description Framework (RDF) syntax. This file gives a snapshot of the thesaurus as of the date tagged in the SKOS ConceptScheme. Additional documentation as well as archived, static versions of the thesaurus are available at: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo-search/study/31892. Please cite the preceding URL, the publication listed at that URL, and the date accessed when referencing the thesaurus.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Paleoclimate\",\"Paleoclimate Reconstructions\"]","dct:title":"Paleoenvironmental Standard Terms (PaST) Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PAST/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2381"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-05-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Paleoscience data are extremely heterogeneous; hundreds of different types of measurements and reconstructions are routinely made by scientists on a variety of types of physical samples. This heterogeneity is one of the biggest barriers to finding paleoclimatic records, to building large-scale data products, and to the use of paleoscience data beyond the community of specialists. Here, we document the Paleoenvironmental Standard Terms (PaST) thesaurus, the first authoritative vocabulary of standardized variable names for paleoclimatic and paleoenvironmental data developed in a formal knowledge organization structure. This structure is designed to improve data set discovery, support automated processing of data, and provide connectivity to other vocabularies. PaST is now used operationally at the World Data Service for Paleoclimatology (WDS-Paleo), one of the largest repositories of paleoscience information. Terms from the PaST thesaurus standardize a broad array of paleoenvironmental and paleoclimatic measured and inferred variables, providing enough detail for accurate and precise data discovery and thereby promoting data reuse. We describe the main design decisions and features of the thesaurus, the governance structure for ongoing maintenance, and WDS-Paleo services that now employ PaST. These services include an advanced search by variable name, an interface for thesaurus navigation, and a machine-readable representation in the Simple Knowledge Organization System (SKOS) standard. This overview is designed for developers of thesauri, data contributors, and users of the WDS-Paleo, and serves as a building block for future efforts within the broader paleoscience community to improve how data are described for long-term findability, accessibility, interoperability, and reusability.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-12-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1029/2020PA004193\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PAST&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PAST/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PAST/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PAST/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PAST&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PAST/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PAST/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PAST","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo-search/cvterms","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo-search/cvterms"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":68,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PAST/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/EARTH\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"Please cite original publication, online resource, dataset and publication DOIs (where available), and date accessed when using downloaded data. If there is no publication information, please cite investigator, title, online resource, and date accessed. The appearance of external links associated with a dataset does not constitute endorsement by the Department of Commerce/National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration of external Web sites or the information, products or services contained therein. For other than authorized activities, the Department of Commerce/NOAA does not exercise any editorial control over the information you may find at these locations. These links are provided consistent with the stated purpose of this Department of Commerce/NOAA Web site.","dct:rightsHolder":"NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":91,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PAST/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":244.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1784},"DWCDOE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcdoe/values/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://dwc.tdwg.org/doe/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DWCDOE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcdoe/values/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://dwc.tdwg.org/doe/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/document","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Degree of Establishment Controlled Vocabulary List of Terms\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Darwin Core term degreeOfEstablishment provides information about degree to which an Organism survives, reproduces, and expands its range at the given place and time. The Degree of Establishment Controlled Vocabulary provides term that should be used as values for dwc:degreeOfEstablishment and dwciri:degreeOfEstablishment","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Darwin Core Degree Of Establishment Controlled Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dwcdoe:","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCDOE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"12"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-03-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-10-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.3897/biss.3.38084\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=DWCDOE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCDOE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCDOE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCDOE/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=DWCDOE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/de, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/es, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCDOE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCDOE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCDOE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcdoe/values/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcdoe/values/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#list)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#list"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":68,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCDOE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#list","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Steve Baskauf"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Peter Desmet\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59fb6c00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59fb6c00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Wilson\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/558560c0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/558560c0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lien Reyserhove\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6e654810-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6e654810-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8815-0078\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8815-0078\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ramona Walls\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paula F. Zermoglio\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/608c7930-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/608c7930-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melodie McGeoch\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4b1d7af0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4b1d7af0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4365-3135\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4365-3135\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Steve Baskauf\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b429020-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b429020-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Annie Simpson\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/65a9b200-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/65a9b200-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tim Adriaens\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/73081a70-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/73081a70-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Quentin Groom\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/77116b00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/77116b00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sonia Vanderhoeven\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45433720-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45433720-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Arthur D. Chapman\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2cd84b30-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2cd84b30-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Damiano Oldoni\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6a2c2460-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6a2c2460-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Wieczorek\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1a357c20-be00-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1a357c20-be00-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"gtuco.btuco@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCDOE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1040},"CODATA-RDMT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://terms.codata.org/rdmt"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://codata.org/initiatives/data-science-and-stewardship/rdm-terminology-wg/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CODATA-RDMT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://terms.codata.org/rdmt","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/AF_c_1403019476795\",\"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q30089794\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10626170","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"CODATA RDM Terminology\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The goal of this terminology is to gather the key terms needed for a common understanding of the research data management domain. Research data management (RDM) refers to the storage, access and preservation of data created or collected in the course of research. Research data management practices cover the entire lifecycle of the data, from planning the investigation to conducting it, and from backing up data as it is created and used to long term preservation of data deliverables after the research investigation has concluded.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"https://terms.codata.org/rdmt/research-data\",\"https://terms.codata.org/rdmt/research-data-lifecycle\"]","dct:title":"CODATA Research Data Management Terminology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://codata.org/\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f07598f0-8a65-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f07598f0-8a65-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"15","omv:numberOfProperties":"12","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"rdm","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"466"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-10-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2022-01-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10626170\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=CODATA-RDMT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"10","dct:modified":"2025-09-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=CODATA-RDMT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"15","schema:associatedMedia":"[\"https://drive.google.com/file/d/1tHVRNy4NoGedQJFFDlxAVQSK4WSi2wFp/view?usp=sharing\"]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"15"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://vocabs.ardc.edu.au]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://vocabs.ardc.edu.au]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://terms.codata.org/rdmt","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://terms.codata.org/rdmt"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10626170"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/AF_c_1403019476795\",\"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q30089794\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10626170","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Laura Molloy"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"https://docs.google.com/document/d/1d9DE0FMuF-xAZHGCRsbNBS-5GKRan4sdylclbY6UeZg/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.cag4la8gg9cb","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"http://purl.org/cld/freq/biennial"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v002"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":260.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1588},"SIBO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/sibo.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/obophenotype/sibo","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SIBO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/obophenotype/sibo/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Social Insect Behavior Ontology (SIBO) was created by Chris Smith. This ontology will eventually be integrated into the NBO ando contains collected terms for Chemical, Anatomy, Behavior, Species. The most developed use cases are for Pogonomyrmex harvester ant foraging and apis mellifera honeybee colony defense.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/obophenotype/sibo/refs/heads/master/sibo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Social Insect Behavior Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/obophenotype/sibo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"525","omv:numberOfProperties":"7","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"sibo","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SIBO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-07-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"4","dct:created":"2025-07-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=SIBO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The Social Insect Behavior Ontology (SIBO) was created by Chris Smith. This ontology will eventually be integrated into the NBO ando contains collected terms for Chemical, Anatomy, Behavior, Species. The most developed use cases are for Pogonomyrmex harvester ant foraging and apis mellifera honeybee colony defense.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SIBO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SIBO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"8","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SIBO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=SIBO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"364","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SIBO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SIBO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SIBO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"158"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://obofoundry.org, https://aber-owl.net, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://obofoundry.org, https://aber-owl.net, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":14.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":83.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/sibo.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/sibo.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SIBO?p=sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SIBO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Chris Mungall"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SIBO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":278.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1229},"EUNIS_HABITATS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/eunishabitats/view","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EUNIS_HABITATS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ENV\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://eunis.eea.europa.eu/habitats.jsp","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/A6","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Classification of habitat types according to the EUNIS Biodiversity database.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/EnvEu_13\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/elter_cl/10597\",\"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/BLH-FHNG3BCR-H\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/elter_cl/10596\"]","dct:title":"EUNIS habitats","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"02k4b9v70\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:02k4b9v70\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"European Environment Agency\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/44daac70-b4ba-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/44daac70-b4ba-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"eunishabitats","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"5283"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/H\",\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/J\",\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/I\",\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/A\",\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/G\",\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/F\",\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/X\",\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/E\",\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/B\",\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/C\",\"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/D\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-01-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The EUNIS Habitat types classification is a comprehensive pan-European system to facilitate the harmonised description and collection of data across Europe through the use of criteria for habitat identification; it covers all types of habitats from natural to artificial, from terrestrial to freshwater and marine.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2014-01-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/search?ontologies=EUNIS_HABITATS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/search?ontologies=EUNIS_HABITATS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://dd.eionet.europa.eu]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://dd.eionet.europa.eu]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/eunishabitats/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#classification_schema)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#classification_schema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ENV\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#classification_schema","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"European Environment Agency"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5261},"WLMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://wildlive.senckenberg.de/wlmo.owl.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://wildlive.senckenberg.de/wlmo/0.3"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"WLMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Applied_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Biodiversity_Conservation\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Environmental_Sciences\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://wildlive.senckenberg.de/wlmo/current/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This semantic artifact describes the semantic relationships between entities which model the setup of a biodiversity monitoring project based on capturing audiovisual digital recordings. It encodes the semantics of the Wildlife Monitoring Ontology and at the same time provides  the datamodel behind the wildlive.senckenberg.de platform.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"The Wildlive Monitoring Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"17","omv:numberOfProperties":"62","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WLMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The ontology developed for representing wildlife monitoring capture events, the setup within which they were observed and their results.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-02-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[\"https://wildlive.senckenberg.de/wlmo/current/relationships.svg\"]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=WLMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WLMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WLMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WLMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=WLMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WLMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WLMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WLMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"15"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://wildlive.senckenberg.de/wlmo.owl.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://wildlive.senckenberg.de/wlmo.owl.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WLMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Applied_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Biodiversity_Conservation\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Environmental_Sciences\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexander Wolodkin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maya Beukes\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/97b1ddd0-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/97b1ddd0-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0351-6523\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0351-6523\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Claus Weiland\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/aef8e810-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/aef8e810-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/714d83a0-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/714d83a0-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-8876-1722\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-8876-1722\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jonas Grieb\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/892a5070-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/892a5070-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-1556-8750\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-1556-8750\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alexander Wolodkin\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/aef8e810-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/aef8e810-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/64940740-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/64940740-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9447-460X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9447-460X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniel Bauer\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/aef8e810-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/aef8e810-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7e3321c0-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7e3321c0-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martin Jansen\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/902ee490-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/902ee490-ed74-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WLMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":264.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":880},"BIOMASSVRE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrebiomass/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIOMASSVRE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrebiomass/","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21762\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20790\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"Researchers, students, data managers, data stewards, and technicians working with virtual research environments related to aquatic and terrestrial biomass.","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrebiomass/c_12bf14d7","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"BIOMASS VRE\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Biomass VRE Thesaurus provides a comprehensive set of concepts designed to enhance the interoperability of data related to both aquatic and terrestrial biomass. Its main goal is to facilitate the harmonisation and integration of heterogeneous datasets that include abiotic and biotic variables, measured in situ or derived from remote sensing observations. The thesaurus includes well-defined terms with corresponding labels, definitions, and semantic relationships covering key concepts associated with aquatic and terrestrial biomass. The Biomass VRE Thesaurus ensures compatibility with other data infrastructures and supports the sharing, comparison, and reuse of biomass-related information across different scientific domains and research communities.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Biomass VRE Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"26","omv:numberOfProperties":"14","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"vrebiomass","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"295"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrebiomass/c_12bf14d7\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrephytoplankton/c_cd8aebf8\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-01-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-01-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=BIOMASSVRE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=BIOMASSVRE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"17"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrebiomass/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrebiomass/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE?p=sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.org/dc/terms/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":13.75,"normalizedScore":42,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.org/dc/terms/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21762\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20790\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Jessica Titocci, Alberto Basset, Teodoro Semeraro]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9157-1578\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9157-1578\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jessica Titocci\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4bd9e680-6787-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4bd9e680-6787-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"jessica.titocci@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9239-9060\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9239-9060\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Teodoro Semeraro\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/80b2ab90-d8d9-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/80b2ab90-d8d9-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"teodoro.semeraro@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0384-5490\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0384-5490\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gianmarco Ingrosso\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/787cdee0-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/787cdee0-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"gianmarco.ingrosso@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9709-6114\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9709-6114\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Francesco De Leo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d7dbec40-d8d9-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d7dbec40-d8d9-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"francesco.deleo@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0009-0001-9691-1989\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0009-0001-9691-1989\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martina Pulieri\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8835-1021\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8835-1021\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Flavio Monti\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6e7e0c80-de88-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6e7e0c80-de88-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"flavio.monti@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0409-2286\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0409-2286\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lorenzo\\tLiberatore\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/037dcad0-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/037dcad0-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lorenzo.liberatore@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[\"The Biomass VRE Thesaurus was generated as part of the activities of work packages 6 and 8 of the ITINERIS project.\"]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOMASSVRE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"Logic-based","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"VocBench\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"ITINERIS\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5390f890-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5390f890-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://itineris.cnr.it\"}"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":63.0,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":285.75,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":475},"FABIO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/spar/fabio"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.org/spar/fabio/2019-02-19"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.sparontologies.net/ontologies/fabio","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"FABIO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/spar/fabio/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://sparontologies.github.io/fabio/current/fabio.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"FaBiO, the FRBR-aligned Bibliographic Ontology, is an ontology for recording and publishing on the Semantic Web descriptions of entities that are published or potentially publishable, and that contain or are referred to by bibliographic references, or entities used to define such bibliographic references. FaBiO entities are primarily textual publications such as books, magazines, newspapers and journals, and items of their content such as poems, conference papers and editorials. However, they also include blogs, web pages, datasets, computer algorithms, experimental protocols, formal specifications and vocabularies, legal records, governmental papers, technical and commercial reports and similar publications, and also anthologies, catalogues and similar collections. \r\n\r\nFaBiO classes are structured according to the FRBR schema of Works, Expressions, Manifestations and Items. Additional properties have been added to extends the FRBR data model by linking Works and Manifestations (fabio:hasManifestation and fabio:isManifestationOf), Works and Items (fabio:hasPortrayal and fabio:isPortrayedBy), and Expressions and Items  (fabio:hasRepresentation and fabio:isRepresentedBy)., conference papers and editorials.  However, catalogues and similar collections. \n\nFaBiO classes are structured according to the FRBR schema of Works, http://purl.org/spar/fabio/FRBR%20diagram%20with%20new%20Fabio%20verbs.png","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/SPAROntologies/fabio/refs/heads/master/docs/current/fabio.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"FRBR-aligned Bibliographic Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"269","omv:numberOfProperties":"138","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"fabio","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"15"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-11-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The FRBR-aligned Bibliographic Ontology (FaBiO) is an ontology for describing entities that are published or potentially publishable (e.g., journal articles, conference papers, books), and that contain or are referred to by bibliographic references. ","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2024-11-25T18:00:05.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://speroni.web.cs.unibo.it/publications/peroni-2012-fabio-cito-ontologies.pdf\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=FABIO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The FRBR-aligned Bibliographic Ontology (FaBiO) is an ontology for describing entities that are published or potentially publishable (e.g., journal articles, conference papers, books), and that contain or are referred to by bibliographic references.\\n\\n**URL:** http://purl.org/spar/fabio\\n\\n**Creators**: [David Shotton](http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5506-523X), [Silvio Peroni](http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0530-4305)\\n\\n**Contributors:** [Paolo Ciccarese](https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5156-2703), [Tim Clark](https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4060-7360)\\n\\n**License:** [Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode)\\n\\n**Website:** http://www.sparontologies.net/ontologies/fabio\\n\\n**Cite as:** Peroni, S., Shotton, D. (2012). FaBiO and CiTO: ontologies for describing bibliographic resources and citations. In Journal of Web Semantics, 17: 33-43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.websem.2012.08.001. Open Access at: http://speroni.web.cs.unibo.it/publications/peroni-2012-fabio-cito-ontologies.pdf\",\"The FRBR-aligned Bibliographic Ontology (FaBiO) is an ontology for describing entities that are published or potentially publishable (e.g., journal articles, conference papers, books), and that contain or are referred to by bibliographic references.\\r\\n\\r\\n**URL:** http://purl.org/spar/fabio\\r\\n\\r\\n**Creators**: [David Shotton](http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5506-523X), [Silvio Peroni](http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0530-4305)\\r\\n\\r\\n**Contributors:** [Paolo Ciccarese](https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5156-2703), [Tim Clark](https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4060-7360)\\r\\n\\r\\n**License:** [Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode)\\r\\n\\r\\n**Website:** http://www.sparontologies.net/ontologies/fabio\\r\\n\\r\\n**Cite as:** Peroni, S., Shotton, D. (2012). FaBiO and CiTO: ontologies for describing bibliographic resources and citations. In Journal of Web Semantics, 17: 33-43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.websem.2012.08.001. Open Access at: http://speroni.web.cs.unibo.it/publications/peroni-2012-fabio-cito-ontologies.pdf\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"33","dct:modified":"2019-02-19T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/FABIO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=FABIO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"58"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://bioportal.bioontology.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://bioportal.bioontology.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":80.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/spar/fabio","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/spar/fabio"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.org/spar/frbr"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.org/spar/frbr","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"http://purl.org/spar/fabio/2018-05-02","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Silvio Peroni, Paolo Ciccarese]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"David Shotton\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/53a77700-9ac1-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/53a77700-9ac1-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Silvio Peroni\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a771b9a0-8d85-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a771b9a0-8d85-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tim Clark\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a7843c70-8d85-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a7843c70-8d85-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paolo Ciccarese\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a7947560-8d85-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a7947560-8d85-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://purl.org/spar/fabio/2018-05-02","owl:versionInfo":"2.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":284.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1790},"OBOE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"OBOE is being used to improve data interpretation, facilitate reuse, and create precise and effective systems for data search and discovery.\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/NCEAS/oboe/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OBOE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/NCEAS/oboe/","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/NCEAS/oboe/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-characteristics.owl#SpectralRadiance","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-characteristics.owl#SpectralRadiance\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Extensible Observation Ontology (OBOE) is a formal ontology for capturing the semantics of scientific observation and measurement. The ontology supports researchers to add detailed semantic annotations to scientific data, thereby clarifying the inherent meaning of scientific observations.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/NCEAS/oboe/master/oboe.owl","omv:keywords":"[\"Environmental science\",\"Biodiversity\",\"Ecology\"]","dct:title":"The Extensible Observation Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"NCEA\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0146z4r19\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:0146z4r19\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Center for Ecological Analysis and Synthesis\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4302c570-fe32-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4302c570-fe32-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"nceas@nceas.ucsb.edu\",\"homepage\":\"https://www.nceas.ucsb.edu/\"}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/NCEAS/oboe"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"292","omv:numberOfProperties":"31","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"oboe","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#UpperLevelOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"OBOE can characterize the context of an observation (e.g., space and time), as well as dependencies such as nested experimental observations. It includes an extensive set of unit definitions (e.g., grams of carbon per liter of seawater), and can facilitate automatic unit conversions (e.g., pounds to kilograms). OBOE can be easily extended to create Entities and Characteristics for specific research domains, making it both broadly applicable and highly customizable.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"5","dct:created":"2025-02-13T18:00:54.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoinf.2007.05.004\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[\"https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S1574954107000362-gr1.jpg\"]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=OBOE&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology contains general terms that are common across OBOE extensions.  It extends the OBOE Core model by importing ontologies specific to measurement characteristics, measurement standards, spatial entities, temporal entities, biological taxa, and anatomical entities.\",\"Copyright (c) 2006-2016 The Regents of the University of California.  All rights reserved. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 444 Castro Street, Suite 900, Mountain View, California, 94041, USA.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"4","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=OBOE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"240","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"70"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://lod-cloud.net/dataset/bioportal-oboe, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://lod-cloud.net/dataset/bioportal-oboe, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":10.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":79.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE?p=sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-core.owl, http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-characteristics.owl, http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-standards.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-core.owl, http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-characteristics.owl, http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-standards.owl]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"Copyright (c) 2006-2016 The Regents of the University of California. All rights reserved. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 444 Castro Street, Suite 900, Mountain View, California, 94041, USA."},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Joshua Madin, Bryce Mecum]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":29.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Deana Pennington\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d39ac170-fe30-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d39ac170-fe30-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"dpennington@LTERnet.edu\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Serguei Krivov\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a23378a0-fe30-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a23378a0-fe30-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"serguei.krivov@uvm.edu\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Christopher Jones\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4b7046f0-cc2d-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4b7046f0-cc2d-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ferdinando Villa\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f51a0490-fe2f-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f51a0490-fe2f-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"ferdinando.villa@uvm.edu\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Benjamin Leinfelder\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/01b3e800-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/01b3e800-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"leinfelder@nceas.ucsb.edu\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joshua Madin\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cc4a0e20-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cc4a0e20-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"joshua.madin@mq.edu.au\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0632-7576\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0632-7576\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mark Schildhauer\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/83ca92e0-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/83ca92e0-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"schild@nceas.ucsb.edu\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Shawn Bowers\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c175d960-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c175d960-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"sbowers@ucdavis.edu\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0077-4738\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0077-4738\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Matthew B. Jones\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b2a5e220-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b2a5e220-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"jones@nceas.ucsb.edu\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-1693-8322\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-1693-8322\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Margaret O'Brien\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/31521bb0-fe35-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/31521bb0-fe35-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"margaret.obrien@ucsb.edu\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"OWL API\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":57.0,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":293.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1779},"ENVTHES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/0PWD-C575"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"https://deims.org/\"]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ENVTHES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"observation\",\"http://semanticscience.org/resource/SIO_001080\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"http://schema.org/Researcher","foaf:page":"https://www.lter-europe.net/lter-europe/data","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/reviews/30f25c90-019c-0139-be80-000c29c082c0, qualityRating=5, updated=2020-11-05T05:53:22.000-08:00, creator=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/pierfrancesco, formalityRating=4, ontologyReviewed=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, created=2020-11-05T05:53:22.000-08:00, documentationRating=5, coverageRating=5, body=First review!, correctnessRating=4, usabilityRating=5, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/reviews/30f25c90-019c-0139-be80-000c29c082c0, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Review, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, body=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/body, ontologyReviewed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, usabilityRating=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/usabilityRating, coverageRating=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/coverageRating, qualityRating=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/qualityRating, formalityRating=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/formalityRating, correctnessRating=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/correctnessRating, documentationRating=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/documentationRating, @language=en}}","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"EnvThes compiles a set of terms in order to describe in a harmonised way data resulting from observations and measurements of ecosystem processes across different domain specific sciences. It is used by DEIMS-SDR for common keywords for annotation and quering metadata purposes.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/LTER-Europe/EnvThes/main/EnvThes.ttl","omv:keywords":"[\"Environmental science\",\"Ecology\",\"Observable properties\"]","dct:title":"Environmental Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://ror.org/00pggkr55\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45caf500-328a-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45caf500-328a-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davide.raho\",\"notation\":\"00pggkr55\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:00pggkr55\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9562c3e0-5f02-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9562c3e0-5f02-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"info@ceh.ac.uk\",\"homepage\":\"https://www.ceh.ac.uk/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"12","omv:numberOfProperties":"11","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"5673"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-11-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"In order to provide a stable semantic backbone the Environmental Thesaurus (EnvThes, see http://vocabs.ceh.ac.uk/evn/tbl/envthes.evn) was developed to provide terms annotating data resulting from long term ecosystem research and monitoring [Schentz et al. 2013]. EnvThes is built on US LTER Controlled Vocabulary (Porter 2010) extending it with links to other vocabularies of domain interest like EUROVOC, GEMET to name just a few.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-11-06T18:00:11.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://www.w3.org/2013/share-psi/wiki/images/0/00/Schentz_et_al_SemanticDataIntegrationforLTER.pdf\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ENVTHES&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2025-06-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ENVTHES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"11","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"11"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://bioportal.bioontology.org/, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/, https://bioportal.bioontology.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://bioportal.bioontology.org/, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/, https://bioportal.bioontology.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":87.0,"normalizedScore":76,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/0PWD-C575"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RIF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RIF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"observation\",\"http://semanticscience.org/resource/SIO_001080\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Barbara Magagna"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0631-8231\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/457f49c0-328a-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/457f49c0-328a-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3565-4624\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4591e6d0-328a-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4591e6d0-328a-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3565-4624\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3565-4624\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Miklós Kertész\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f241fcd0-0e3d-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f241fcd0-0e3d-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1068-2394\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45a4cf60-328a-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45a4cf60-328a-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0631-8231\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0631-8231\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Johannes Peterseil\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/07e65e20-0e3e-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/07e65e20-0e3e-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0320-0692\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/454ff8b0-328a-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/454ff8b0-328a-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2195-3997\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2195-3997\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Barbara Magagna\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0320-0692\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0320-0692\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ulf Grandin\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/da3b93a0-0e3d-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/da3b93a0-0e3d-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-1068-2394\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-1068-2394\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mark  Frenzel\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b37bb240-0e3d-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b37bb240-0e3d-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b38b1080-0e3d-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b38b1080-0e3d-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2195-3997\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2195-3997\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Barbara Magagna\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[\"Barbara Magagna\"]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"http://purl.org/cld/freq/continuous"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"5.0.16"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"eLTER\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Integrated European Long-Term Ecosystem, critical zone and socio-ecological Research\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/feebab20-0ef4-013c-a970-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/feebab20-0ef4-013c-a970-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":17.0,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/eLTER+PLUS, name=Integrated European Long-Term Ecosystem, critical zone and socio-ecological Research infrastructure Advanced Community project, updated=2023-04-18T18:07:14.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL], acronym=eLTER PLUS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue], created=2023-04-18T18:07:14.000+00:00, homePage=https://elter-ri.eu/elter-plus, contacts=Michael Mirtl, michael.mirtl@ufz.de , description=eLTER PLUS connects major scientific user communities with the site networks and its data/services, works on detailed site and observation specifications and pilots the technical service development, institution=University of Helsinki, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/eLTER+PLUS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":43,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":292.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1148},"PALEO_VARIABLES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_variables#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_variables/2.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://linked.earth/ontology/#IntegrationTime","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PALEO_VARIABLES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_variables#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_variables/2.0.0/index-en.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_variables#accumulation","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Paleo Variables Ontology defines different types of paleo variables that we can find in a paleo climate dataset.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"The Paleo Variables Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"pvars","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"299"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[\"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_variables#PaleoVariable\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-12-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=PALEO_VARIABLES&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Cite as:\\r\\nhttp://earth.usc.edu/~khider/, http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5920-4751, http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/. The Paleo Variables Ontology. Revision: 2.0.0. Retrieved from: http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_variables/2.0.0\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=PALEO_VARIABLES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_variables#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_variables#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.5,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":53.5,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Julien Emile-Geay"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paleoclimate Dynamics Laboratory\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5920-4751\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5920-4751\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julien Emile-Geay\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://w3id.org/people/varunr\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e979b700-938b-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e979b700-938b-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":263.5,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":822},"FISHTRAITS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fishtraits/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":9.0,"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.80186/59ny-cy42"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"FISHTRAITS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Fish Traits Thesaurus\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Fish Traits Thesaurus is the first initiative to deal with the semantics of fish functional traits. It has been developed by LifeWatch Italy, the Italian node of the e-science European infrastructure for biodiversity and ecosystem research (LifeWatch ERIC). FishTraits reflects the agreement of a scientific expert community to fix semantic properties (e.g. label, definition, relationships) of approximately 220 concepts. This resource has been deprecated. The concepts can be consulted in https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/traits/.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Fish Traits Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"LifeWatch Italy\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lifewatchitaly@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"146"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2023-09-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2015-03-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://www.lifewatchitaly.eu/web/lifewatch-italia/reports\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=FISHTRAITS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/ontologies/FISHTRAITS/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=FISHTRAITS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fishtraits/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.80186/59ny-cy42"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fishtraits/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"local:local\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"true","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/TRAITS_THES"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS/submissions/1","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/TRAITS_THES","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":43,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Ilaria Rosati"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Claudia Miglietta\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f9293260-0e41-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f9293260-0e41-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3422-7230\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3422-7230\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ilaria Rosati\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS/submissions/1","owl:versionInfo":"1.5"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":263.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":704},"WISE_CLASS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/wise/ClassificationSystem/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/wise/ClassificationSystem/view","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"WISE_CLASS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/wise/ClassificationSystem/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/wise/ClassificationSystem/AMBI","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Codes of classification systems that are applied to biological quality elements for the classification of ecological status of surface water bodies.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"WISE Classification system","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ClassificationSystem","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"311"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-01-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-12-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/search?ontologies=WISE_CLASS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/ontologies/WISE_CLASS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/search?ontologies=WISE_CLASS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://dd.eionet.europa.eu]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://dd.eionet.europa.eu]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/wise/ClassificationSystem/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/wise/ClassificationSystem/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"European Environment Agency"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":260.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1289},"SFWO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/sfwo.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.org/sfwo/releases/2023-09-22/sfwo.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://soilfoodwebontology.github.io","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SFWO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/sfwo/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://soilfoodwebontology.github.io/documentation.html","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/soilfoodwebontology/sfwo/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://purl.org/sfwo/SFWO_0000128","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soilbio.2023.109282\",\"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejsobi.2023.103497\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Soil Food Web Ontology (SFWO) describes concepts related to the trophic ecology of soil organisms, including diets, food resources, trophic processes, and trophic groups, across taxonomic groups and trophic levels. SFWO aims at being both a reference ontology -including a standardised vocabulary- for soil trophic ecology, and an application ontology, with a focus on reasoning-based applications.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://github.com/soilfoodwebontology/sfwo/releases/latest/download/sfwo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Soil Food Web Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/soilfoodwebontology/sfwo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"834","omv:numberOfProperties":"136","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"sfwo","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"386"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2023-09-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoinf.2023.102360\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[\"https://soilfoodwebontology.github.io/images/sfwo_core.png\"]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=SFWO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"183","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/SFWO/download","foaf:logo":"https://soilfoodwebontology.github.io/images/logo.png","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=SFWO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"415","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"42"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":82.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/sfwo.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/sfwo.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pato#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ncbitaxon#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chebi/, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro/subsets#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uberon/core#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/envo#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ncbitaxon/subsets/taxslim#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.57,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.57,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pato#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ncbitaxon#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chebi/, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro/subsets#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uberon/core#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/envo#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ncbitaxon/subsets/taxslim#]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"http://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SFWO/sub","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":53.57,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"33"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Nicolas Le Guillarme, Mickaël Hedde]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nicolas Le Guillarme\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3bbff5c0-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3bbff5c0-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mickaël Hedde\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3bea3750-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3bea3750-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Anton M. Potapov\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3bd308a0-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3bd308a0-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Carlos A. Martínez-Muñoz\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c5a80f0-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c5a80f0-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maria J.I. Briones\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c202ce0-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c202ce0-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Matty P. Berg\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3cab1930-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3cab1930-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Irene Calderón-Sanou\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c049e80-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c049e80-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"David J. Russell\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c8ad310-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c8ad310-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Benjamin Pey\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c13beb0-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c13beb0-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Camille Martinez Almoyna\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c6c1860-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c6c1860-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Florine Degrune\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c4b3560-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c4b3560-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Karin Hohberg\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c9e9f40-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c9e9f40-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Wilfried Thuiller\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c36d530-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3c36d530-99d5-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SFWO/sub","owl:versionInfo":"2023-09-22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":289.57,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1870},"MRPTCODELIST":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://marineregions.org/ns/placetypes"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.marineregions.org/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MRPTCODELIST","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://marineregions.org/ns/placetypes","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Marine Regions PlaceType code list provides definitions for the PlaceTypes used in the Marine Regions dataset.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://marineregions.org/ns/placetypes","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Marine Regions PlaceTypes code list","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MRPTCODELIST/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"343"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-22T18:00:18.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://www.vliz.be/en/imis?refid=346947\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=MRPTCODELIST&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MRPTCODELIST/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MRPTCODELIST/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/MRPTCODELIST/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=MRPTCODELIST&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MRPTCODELIST/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MRPTCODELIST/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MRPTCODELIST","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://marineregions.org/ns/placetypes","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://marineregions.org/ns/placetypes"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MRPTCODELIST/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Marine Regions Data Management team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MRPTCODELIST/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":232.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":699},"FOVT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/fovt.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/fovt/releases/2026-03-19/fovt.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://futres.org","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"FOVT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/fovt/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/futres/fovt/blob/master/README.md","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/futres/fovt/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"FuTRES Ontology of Vertebrate Traits is an application ontology used to convert vertebrate trait data in spreadsheet to triples. FOVT leverages the BioCollections Ontology (BCO) to link observations of individual specimens to their trait values. Traits are defined in the Ontology of Biological Attributes (OBA). For more details on FOVT, see https://futres.org/., None, These are the terms that are improted for FOVT to describe vertebrate traits.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/futres/fovt/master/fovt.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"FuTRES Ontology of Vertebrate Traits","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"11981","omv:numberOfProperties":"321","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"fovt","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"383"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-03-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"97","dct:created":"2026-03-20T18:00:18.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/search?ontologies=FOVT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1898","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/ontologies/FOVT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/search?ontologies=FOVT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"780","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1708"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://obofoundry.org, https://aber-owl.net, https://bioregistry.io, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://obofoundry.org, https://aber-owl.net, https://bioregistry.io, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":14.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/fovt.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/fovt.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pato.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/oba.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uberon.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bspo.owl, http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/ontologies/BCO, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pato.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/oba.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uberon.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bspo.owl, http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/ontologies/BCO, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"38"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Meghan Balk"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2026-03-19"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":49.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":292.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1539},"LITHOLOGY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/lithology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?lang=en","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LITHOLOGY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/lithology/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/lithology/231","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The theme Lithology comprises loose- and bed-rock, that were classified according to their modal composition or their grain size, respectively. The classification of magmatic-, polygenetic-, metamorphic- and fault-rocks are based on the IUGS recommendations by the sub-commissions for magmatic and metamorphic rocks, respectively. The classification of sedimentary unconsolidated and solid rocks was based on the grain size classification and, where not applicable, on common international standards.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/26L-SR7F4VQX-7\",\"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/26L-FJC28G8N-6\",\"https://terra-vocabulary.org/ncl/FAIR-Incubator/earthfeaturetype/c_582c60b7\"]","dct:title":"Lithology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"lithology","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"327"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/lithology/97&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/lithology/158&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/lithology/1&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/lithology/249&lang=en\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-11-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2019-07-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/bibl_res.html?proj=lithology\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=LITHOLOGY&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LITHOLOGY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=LITHOLOGY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/lithology/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/lithology/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://resource.geolba.ac.at/PoolParty/sparql/lithology\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/at/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.75,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/at/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Geological Survey of Austria"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Schiegl M.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7be3ab80-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7be3ab80-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Huet B.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/484c5bb0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/484c5bb0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Reiser M.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/79df5560-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/79df5560-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dobramysl L.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/137df220-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/137df220-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Linner M.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/60648870-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/60648870-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Iglseder Ch.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4f010d80-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4f010d80-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Reitner J.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/88bbf8f0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/88bbf8f0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Haider V.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3aa4b7b0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3aa4b7b0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ebner M.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/33610d90-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/33610d90-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Schuster R.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/948fdeb0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/948fdeb0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Krenmayr H.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/55743700-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/55743700-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Palzer-Khomenko M.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6bb2c410-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6bb2c410-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Auer Ch.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f52363d0-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f52363d0-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lipiarski P.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/660fea80-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/660fea80-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pavlik B.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/727bdce0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/727bdce0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Weber L.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9a4eac10-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9a4eac10-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Schedl A.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8eb5f5c0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8eb5f5c0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hintersberger E.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/420b6050-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/420b6050-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hörfarter Ch.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cb3e5060-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cb3e5060-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":55.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":265.75,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1035},"BCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bco.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bco/releases/2021-11-14/bco.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"This ontology can be used to describe physical samples and sampling processes (for example, collection, extraction, and preservation techniques), as well as biodiversity observations that involve no physical sampling.\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/BiodiversityOntologies/bco","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bco_","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21673\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/BiodiversityOntologies/bco/wiki","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/BiodiversityOntologies/bco/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bco_0000036","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"BioCollections Ontology\"]","doap:mailing-list":"bco-discuss@googlegroups.com","dct:description":"The goal of the BCO is to support the interoperability of biodiversity data, including data on museum collections, environmental/metagenomic samples, and ecological surveys. The BCO covers distinctions between individuals, organisms, voucher specimens, lots, samples, the relations between these entities, and the processes governing the creation and use of \"samples\". Also within scope are properties including collector, location, time, storage environment, containers, institution, and collection identifiers., The BCO supports the interoperability of biodiversity and biodiversity related data, and ecological surveys. A key aspect of the BCO is distinguishing among material samples (i.e. specimens), observing processes, and data about either of those entities.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.biodivportal.gfbio.org/ontologies/BCO/download?apikey=8d904e8e-41f9-454d-bbca-5184a9da4109","omv:keywords":"[\"Environmental samples\"]","dct:title":"BioCollections Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Biodiversity Ontologies\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b077dbe0-1092-013c-61d0-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b077dbe0-1092-013c-61d0-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/BiodiversityOntologies/bco"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"254","omv:numberOfProperties":"378","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"bco","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"64"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2022-02-04T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2021-11-04T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0089606\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[\"http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/figure/image?size=large&id=info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0089606.g002\"]","void:openSearchDescription":"null","schema:comment":"[\"The Biological Collections Ontology was originally created at the Biocode Commons Hackathon at GSC14. Older versions can be viewed at http://code.google.com/p/biocode-commons/source/browse/#svn%2Ftrunk%2Fontologies%2Fbiocollections.\\r\\nThis is the editor's version of the ontology. Use with caution. For the live version of the ontology, use http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bco.owl. \\r\\n\\r\\nThe Biological Collections Ontology was originally created at the Biocode Commons Hackathon at GSC14. Older versions can be viewed at http://code.google.com/p/biocode-commons/source/browse/#svn%2Ftrunk%2Fontologies%2Fbiocollections. Some of the classes in this ontology may be replaced by existing or newly requested terms from OBI or other ontologies.\",\"This is the editor's version of the ontology. Use with caution. For the live version of the ontology, use http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bco.owl.\\n\\nThe Biological Collections Ontology was originally created at the Biocode Commons Hackathon at GSC14. Older versions can be viewed at http://code.google.com/p/biocode-commons/source/browse/#svn%2Ftrunk%2Fontologies%2Fbiocollections.  Some of the classes in this ontology may be replaced by existing or newly requested terms from OBI or other ontologies.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"55","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"null","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"null","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"67","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"39"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://obofoundry.org, https://aber-owl.net, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://obofoundry.org, https://aber-owl.net, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":94.0,"normalizedScore":83,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bco.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bco.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"null","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":90,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":99.0,"normalizedScore":87,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/envo.owl, http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/ontologies/PCO]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.75,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#hasExactSynonym","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21673\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/IAO_0000115","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/envo.owl, http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/ontologies/PCO]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/IAO_0000115","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#hasExactSynonym"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"30"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Ramona Walls"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8815-0078\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8815-0078\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ramona Walls\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8815-0078\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8815-0078\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ramona Walls\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Barry Smith\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/da36f170-b4ad-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/da36f170-b4ad-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Robert Guralnick\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bd7a89e0-b4ad-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bd7a89e0-b4ad-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Deck\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d275db10-b4ad-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d275db10-b4ad-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Wieczorek\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1a357c20-be00-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1a357c20-be00-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"gtuco.btuco@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Biocode Commons Ontology Hackathon members\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c617ac20-b4ad-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c617ac20-b4ad-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2021-11-14"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"OWL API\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":293.75,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1232},"DCSO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/dcso/ns/core"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/dcso/ns/core/4.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DCSO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/RDA-DMP-Common/RDA-DMP-Common-Standard/blob/master/ontologies/README.md","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This ontology aims to represent the DMP Common Standard model, through the usage of semantic web technology. It represents the DMP Common Standard model using the Web Ontology Language (OWL).,  This ontology aims to represent the DMP Common Standard model","omv:resourceLocator":"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"The DMP Common Standard Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"24","omv:numberOfProperties":"61","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dcso","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#ApplicationOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#Host\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#ContactId\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#License\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#Funding\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#DatasetId\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#TechnicalResource\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#Distribution\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#SecurityPrivacy\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#FunderId\",\"https://w3id.org/dcso/ns/core#Contact\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#Metadata\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#Cost\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#Project\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#DMP\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#MetadataStandardId\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#ContributorId\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#GrantId\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#Dataset\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#Id\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#Contributor\",\"https://semantics.id/ns/dcso/index-en.html#DMPId\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-07-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-07-18T18:00:04.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8443/search?ontologies=DCSO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8443/ontologies/DCSO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8443/search?ontologies=DCSO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"13"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":74.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/dcso/ns/core","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/dcso/ns/core"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.61,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat#, http://purl.org/dc/dcam, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://schema.org/, https://w3id.org/dcso/id/example, http://xmlns.com/wot/0.1, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.61,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.61,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Fajar J. Ekaputra"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fajar J. Ekaputra\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a3d60d10-462f-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a3d60d10-462f-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Leyla Garcia\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/46059ca0-9935-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/46059ca0-9935-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"João Cardoso\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8ec09ce0-993b-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8ec09ce0-993b-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie Christine Jacquemot\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45da1b50-9935-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45da1b50-9935-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Suchánek Marek\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a4193f50-462f-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a4193f50-462f-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniel Faria\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a49cf220-462f-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a49cf220-462f-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tomasz Miksa\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a44ffb30-462f-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a44ffb30-462f-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Diogo Proença\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a4628370-462f-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a4628370-462f-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"4.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":276.61,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1772},"CMECS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/CMECS/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14940832"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://iocm.noaa.gov/standards/cmecs-home.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CMECS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/elter_cl/10501\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/68\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21811\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21759\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20295\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21741\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20909\"]","dct:coverage":"U.S. waters from head-of-tide to ocean bottom, and Great Lakes","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/NOAA-OCM","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/NOAA-OCM/cmecs","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/*Chaetomorpha*Communities","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/234388c9979443618fb7549bf3f95211\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"CMECS\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Coastal and Marine Ecological Classification Standard (CMECS, FGDC-STD-018-2012) ) is a collection of terms and and definitions (units) for classifying and describing aquatic environments. Units are organized in a framework of thematic, interrelated, semi-hierarchical components and settings designed for analyzing and mapping observational data within geographic information systems (GIS). CMECS is a U.S. National Ecological Classification Standard published by the US Federal Geographic Data Committee (FGDC). , The Coastal and Marine Ecological Classification Standard (CMECS) is a collection of terms and and definitions for classifying and describing aquatic environments. The vocabulary is organized in a framework of thematic, semi-hierarchical Components and Settings categories., The Coastal and Marine Ecological Classifcation Standard (CMECS) is a collection of terms and and defintions for classifying and describing aquatic environments. The vocabulary is organized in a framework of thematic, semi-heirarchical components and settings.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Biota\",\"Lacustrine\",\"Benthic Habitat\"]","dct:title":"Coastal and Marine Ecological Classification Standard Catalog","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/NOAA-OCM/cmecs"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1690","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CMECS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#ApplicationOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"9","dct:created":"2024-05-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://repository.library.noaa.gov/view/noaa/27552\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=CMECS&q=","schema:comment":"[\"https://github.com/NOAA-OCM/cmecs/releases/tag/v1.1.1\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CMECS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CMECS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"85","dct:modified":"2025-02-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CMECS/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=CMECS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"625","schema:associatedMedia":"[\"https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/products/coastal-marine-ecological-classification-standard\"]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CMECS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CMECS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CMECS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"70"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://bioportal.bioontology.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://bioportal.bioontology.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":83.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/CMECS/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14940832"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/CMECS/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"local:local\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CMECS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/elter_cl/10501\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/68\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21811\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21759\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20295\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21741\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20909\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#comment","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#comment","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"https://repository.library.noaa.gov/view/noaa/27552","dct:rightsHolder":"Kate Rose"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":91,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/katerose\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8454-8481\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/97595b90-165e-013f-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/97595b90-165e-013f-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CMECS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":57.0,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":289.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2156},"INBIO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/inbio"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.6826848"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/inbio/1.2.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"INBIO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Population_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://fusion-jena.github.io/INBIO/documentation/index-en.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Invasion Biology Ontology (INBIO) contains terms and concepts relevant in the field of invasion biology, which is a research area dealing with the translocation, establishment, spread, impact and management of species outside of their native ranges, where they are called non-native or alien species. This first version of the ontology covers terms and concepts needed to describe twelve major invasion hypotheses building the hierarchical hypothesis network (see also Jeschke JM, Heger T (Eds) (2018) Invasion Biology: Hypotheses and Evidence. CABI, Wallingford, UK).","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Invasion Biology Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"495","omv:numberOfProperties":"113","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"62"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-07-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2022-12-07T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[\"https://fusion-jena.github.io/INBIO/documentation/diagram.png\"]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=INBIO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The Invasion Biology Ontology (INBIO) contains terms and concepts relevant in the field of invasion biology, which is a research area dealing with the translocation, establishment, spread, impact and management of species outside of their native ranges, where they are called non-native or alien species. This first version of the ontology covers terms and concepts needed to describe twelve major invasion hypotheses building the hierarchical hypothesis network (see also Jeschke JM, Heger T (Eds) (2018) Invasion Biology: Hypotheses and Evidence. CABI, Wallingford, UK).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"107","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/INBIO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=INBIO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"120","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"19"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":82.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/inbio","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.6826848"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/inbio"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://cerrado.linkeddata.es/ecology/ccon#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/geo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pato.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uberon.owl, https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PCO, http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-core.owl#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/go.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ncbitaxon.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/obi.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chebi.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://cerrado.linkeddata.es/ecology/ccon#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/geo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pato.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uberon.owl, https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PCO, http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-core.owl#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/go.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ncbitaxon.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/obi.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chebi.owl]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Population_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"29"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Alsayed Algergawy, Tina Heger]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-8550-4720\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-8550-4720\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alsayed Algergawy\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/31cea6b0-99fd-013d-4e42-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/31cea6b0-99fd-013d-4e42-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"alsayed.algergawy@uni-jena.de\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-5522-5632\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-5522-5632\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tina Heger\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dd404390-4f60-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dd404390-4f60-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"t.heger@tum.de\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4481-069X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4481-069X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Merle Gänßinger\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dd225970-4f60-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dd225970-4f60-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"merle.gaenssinger@uni-jena.de\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Hrishikesh Jad\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dd0313d0-4f60-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dd0313d0-4f60-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"havjadhav02@ads.uni-passau.de\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-2382-9722\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-2382-9722\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Birgitta König-Riese\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dd804580-4f60-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dd804580-4f60-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"birgitta.koenig-ries@uni-jena.de\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":283.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2289},"PALEO_UNITS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_units#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_units/2.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://linked.earth/ontology/#IntegrationTime","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PALEO_UNITS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_units#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_units/2.0.0/index-en.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_units/2.0.0/index-en.html#atomic_ratio","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Paleo Units Ontology defines different types of paleo units that we can find in a paleo climate dataset.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_units/2.0.0/ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"The Paleo Units Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"punits","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"71"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[\"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_units#PaleoUnit\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-12-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=PALEO_UNITS&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Cite as:\\r\\nhttp://earth.usc.edu/~khider/, http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5920-4751, http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/. The Paleo Units Ontology. Revision: 2.0.0. Retrieved from: http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_units/2.0.0\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=PALEO_UNITS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_units#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_units#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.5,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":53.5,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Deborah Khider"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paleoclimate Dynamics Laboratory\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5920-4751\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5920-4751\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julien Emile-Geay\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://w3id.org/people/varunr\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e979b700-938b-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e979b700-938b-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":271.5,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":564},"DWCPW":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcpw/values/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/doc/pw/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DWCPW","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/alienspecies/c_1\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Darwin Core Pathway Controlled Vocabulary\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Darwin Core term pathway provides information about the process by which an Organism came to be in a given place at a given time. The Pathway Controlled Vocabulary provides terms that should be used as values for dwc:pathway and dwciri:pathway.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Darwin Core Pathway Controlled Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"TDWG Darwin Core Maintenance Group\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d578a610-0e43-013c-7f1b-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d578a610-0e43-013c-7f1b-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCPW/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"108"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2022-01-04T13:58:45.000-08:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-01-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.3897/biss.3.38084\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"null","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCPW/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCPW/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"null","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"null","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCPW/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCPW/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCPW","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"3"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcpw/values/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcpw/values/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"null","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":90,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":90.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":68,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"null","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"null","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCPW/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/alienspecies/c_1\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"null","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"null","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":3.0,"normalizedScore":9,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"null","mod:prefLabelProperty":"null","mod:authorProperty":"null","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":1.0,"normalizedScore":3,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[ John Wieczorek, Steve Baskauf]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Peter Desmet\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59fb6c00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59fb6c00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Wilson\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/558560c0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/558560c0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lien Reyserhove\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6e654810-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6e654810-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8815-0078\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8815-0078\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ramona Walls\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paula F. Zermoglio\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/608c7930-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/608c7930-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melodie McGeoch\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4b1d7af0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4b1d7af0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4365-3135\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4365-3135\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Steve Baskauf\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b429020-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b429020-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Annie Simpson\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/65a9b200-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/65a9b200-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tim Adriaens\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/73081a70-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/73081a70-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Quentin Groom\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/77116b00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/77116b00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sonia Vanderhoeven\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45433720-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45433720-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Damiano Oldoni\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6a2c2460-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6a2c2460-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Wieczorek\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1a357c20-be00-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1a357c20-be00-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"gtuco.btuco@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCPW/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2021-09-01"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":229.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":824},"CPMETA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://meta.icos-cp.eu/ontologies/cpmeta/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"ENVRI metadata schema\",\"Configuration of metadata editing interfaces\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/ICOS-Carbon-Portal/meta/blob/master/src/main/resources/owl/cpmeta.owl","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CPMETA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://meta.icos-cp.eu/ontologies/cpmeta/","dct:subject":"[\"Ecosystem greenhouse gas exchange\",\"Ocean greenhouse gas exchange\",\"Atmospheric composition\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"ICOS Carbon Portal developers","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"https://meta.fieldsites.se/edit/sitesmeta/\",\"https://meta.icos-cp.eu/edit/cpmeta/\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"ICOS Ontology\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"OWL vocabulary describing metadata of two environmental research infrastructures: ICOS and SITES, as well as of a pilot project ICOS Cities, as well as of spin-off project ICOS Cities","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Sensors\",\"Sites\",\"Environmental research infrastructures\",\"Observable properties\"]","dct:title":"Ontology of Integrated Carbon Observation System (ICOS)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"79","omv:numberOfProperties":"155","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"cpmeta","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"99"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-02-09T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2015-05-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=CPMETA&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"11","dct:modified":"2024-02-09T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=CPMETA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"72","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"19"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://meta.icos-cp.eu/ontologies/cpmeta/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://meta.icos-cp.eu/ontologies/cpmeta/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://meta.icos-cp.eu/sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.57,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/ns/ssn/, http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://creativecommons.org/ns#, http://schema.org/, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.57,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"Ecosystem greenhouse gas exchange\",\"Ocean greenhouse gas exchange\",\"Atmospheric composition\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.57,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Oleg Mirzov, Alex Vermeulen]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-4742-958X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-4742-958X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Oleg Mirzov\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27fd52b0-982f-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27fd52b0-982f-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"oleg.mirzov@nateko.lu.se\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mirzov\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jonathan Thiry\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9cf83050-a89b-013c-1b52-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9cf83050-a89b-013c-1b52-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"jonathan.thiry@nateko.lu.se\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"OWL DL","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"http://protege.stanford.edu\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#ConfigurationTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#SearchTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":15.0,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":275.57,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":834},"SUMSO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.w3id.org/sumso"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.w3id.org/sumso#v1.0.1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.w3id.org/sumso/repo","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SUMSO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/OTHER\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ENV\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://air.unimi.it/handle/2434/1161515","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Sustainable Meat Systems Ontology (SuMSO) is a domain ontology addressing meat systems sustainability. It extends Sustainability Core Ontology (SCO) and Basic Formal Ontology (BFO). Currently, SuMSO provides a representation of the core architectural features of a sustainable meat system, focusing on cow-derived meat as an initial use case. SuMSO deals with meat in a broad sense: it contemplates the liaisons with other cow-derived materials, such as leather and bones., SuMSO is a domain of ontology, representing meat systems sustainability.\r\n\r\nCurrently, this resource provides the core ontological module of SuMSO that deals with the essential architectural features of a sustainable meat system. This ontological module addresses meat in a broad, genuine sense focusing on cow-derived meat as a starting use-case example. It does not address features related to fish, insects, novel meats, and plant-based meats. The SuMSO core ontological module aims to be the starting basis on which to extend SuMSO to more comprehensively represent meat systems sustainability., representing meat systems sustainability.\n\nCurrently","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Sustainable Development\",\"Sustainability\",\"Meat Systems\"]","dct:title":"Sustainable Meat Systems Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"470","omv:numberOfProperties":"284","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SUMSO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"7"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-08-09T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://air.unimi.it/handle/2434/1161515\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=SUMSO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SUMSO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SUMSO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"145","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SUMSO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=SUMSO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"19","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SUMSO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SUMSO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SUMSO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":75.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.w3id.org/sumso","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.w3id.org/sumso"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.w3id.org/sco]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.w3id.org/sco]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SUMSO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://github.com/gioUbbiali/Sustainable-Meat-Systems-Ontology/releases/tag/v1.0.0","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/OTHER\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ENV\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"15"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Giorgio A. Ubbiali"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/gioUbbi\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/gioUbbi\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-7872-1770\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-7872-1770\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Giorgio A. Ubbiali\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5c8ad9c0-572c-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5c8ad9c0-572c-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/gioUbbi\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/gioUbbi\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-6148-7962\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-6148-7962\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Matthew C. Lange\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/99c07790-572c-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/99c07790-572c-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/gioUbbi\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/gioUbbi\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-2239-1482\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-2239-1482\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrea Borghini\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/755c4cd0-572c-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/755c4cd0-572c-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SUMSO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://github.com/gioUbbiali/Sustainable-Meat-Systems-Ontology/releases/tag/v1.0.0","owl:versionInfo":"2025-06-13"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":274.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1609},"EBVS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/ad4gd/ev/ebv"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EBVS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://w3id.org/ad4gd/ev/\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://w3id.org/ad4gd/ev/EBV","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This is a vocabulary of the Essential Biodiversity Variables mapped with I-ADOPT framework., Essential Biodiversity Variables (EBVs) are defined as a minimum set of measurements, complementary to one another, that can capture major dimensions of biodiversity change. EBVs are organized in six classes (Genetic composition, Species populations, Species traits, Community composition, Ecosystem functioning, Ecosystem structure) and cover the three realms (Marine/coastal, Terrestrial and Freshwater)","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/AD4GD/GDIM/refs/heads/main/EVs/ebv.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Essential Biodiversity Variables","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"15","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EBVS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"696"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-04-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-04-08T18:00:19.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=EBVS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EBVS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EBVS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EBVS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=EBVS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"14","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EBVS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EBVS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EBVS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/ad4gd/ev/ebv","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/ad4gd/ev/ebv"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EBVS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://w3id.org/ad4gd/ev/\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Victoria Lush, Ivette Serral]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"http://www.opengis.net/def/entities/bodies/ogcna\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EBVS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":210.0,"normalizedScore":43,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1115},"ICOS_INST":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/icos_instruments/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ICOS_INST","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Environmental_Sciences\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ENV\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This vocabulary includes a list of instrument types and models used by ICOS ERIC.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"ICOS Instruments Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"28","omv:numberOfProperties":"13","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ICOS_INST/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"793"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-04-07T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-04-07T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ICOS_INST&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ICOS_INST/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ICOS_INST/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ICOS_INST/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ICOS_INST&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"6","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ICOS_INST/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ICOS_INST/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ICOS_INST","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"19"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/icos_instruments/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/icos_instruments/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ICOS_INST/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Environmental_Sciences\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ENV\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Dario Papale"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ICOS_INST/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":219.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":223},"DWCEM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcem/values/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwc/doc/em/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DWCEM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcem/values/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Darwin Core Establishment Means Controlled Vocabulary\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Darwin Core term establishmentMeans provides information about whether an organism or organisms have been introduced to a given place and time through the direct or indirect activity of modern humans. The Establishment Means Controlled Vocabulary provides terms that should be used as values for dwc:establishmentMeans and dwciri:establishmentMeans.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Darwin Core Establishment Means Controlled Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"TDWG Darwin Core Maintenance Group\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d578a610-0e43-013c-7f1b-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d578a610-0e43-013c-7f1b-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"TDWG\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Biodiversity Information Standards\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/35835710-b9cf-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/35835710-b9cf-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"secretary@tdwg.org\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dwcem","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCEM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"14"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2021-12-23T01:19:11.000-08:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-09-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.3897/biss.3.38084\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"null","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCEM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCEM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"null","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"null","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCEM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCEM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCEM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"3"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcem/values/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/dwcem/values/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"null","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":90,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":90.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":68,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"null","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"local:Darwin","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCEM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCEM/submissions/1","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"null","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"local:TDWG","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":12,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"null","mod:prefLabelProperty":"local:Darwin","mod:authorProperty":"local:TDWG","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.0,"normalizedScore":9,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[John Wieczorek, Steve Baskauf]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Peter Desmet\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59fb6c00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59fb6c00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Wilson\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/558560c0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/558560c0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lien Reyserhove\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6e654810-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6e654810-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paula F. Zermoglio\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/608c7930-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/608c7930-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melodie McGeoch\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4b1d7af0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4b1d7af0-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4365-3135\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4365-3135\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Steve Baskauf\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b429020-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b429020-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Annie Simpson\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/65a9b200-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/65a9b200-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Quentin Groom\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/77116b00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/77116b00-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sonia Vanderhoeven\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45433720-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/45433720-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Arthur D. Chapman\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2cd84b30-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2cd84b30-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Damiano Oldoni\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6a2c2460-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6a2c2460-6874-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Wieczorek\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1a357c20-be00-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1a357c20-be00-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"gtuco.btuco@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCEM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DWCEM/submissions/1","owl:versionInfo":"2021-09-01"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":233.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":763},"SPO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/spo/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/spo/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SPO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/GEO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/EARTH\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ENV\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The LifeWatch Italy Semantic Platform Ontology is a graph-based data model designed to integrate and represent datasets produced by biodiversity and ecosystem researchers in LifeWatch Italy, along with the associated metadata. This semantic framework is implemented within the LifeWatch Italy Semantic Platform, offering users a browser to navigate ontology classes, a search engine, a SPARQL query endpoint, and other related services. The ontology developed by reusing LifeWatch Italy Domain Ontology, several term from Data Catalog Vocabulary, The PROV Ontology, FOAF Vocabulary Specification, and I-ADOPT Framework, enhancing interoperability and facilitating integration with other systems using these standards. The design of the ontology adheres to FAIR principles. It uses persistent identifiers, OWL2 for knowledge representation, semantic versioning, and rich metadata, including licensing and provenance details.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Biodiversity\",\"Semantic Integration\"]","dct:title":"LifeWatch Italy Semantic Platform Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"21","omv:numberOfProperties":"83","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SPO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[\"Feature Of Interest\",\"Catalog\",\"Observation\",\"Observable Property\",\"Dataset\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-10-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-10-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=SPO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The LifeWatch Italy Semantic Platform Ontology is a graph-based data model designed to integrate and represent datasets produced by biodiversity and ecosystem researchers in LifeWatch Italy, along with the associated metadata. This semantic framework is implemented within the LifeWatch Italy Semantic Platform, offering users a browser to navigate ontology classes, a search engine, a SPARQL query endpoint, and other related services.\\nThe ontology developed by reusing LifeWatch Italy Domain Ontology, several term from Data Catalog Vocabulary, The PROV Ontology, FOAF Vocabulary Specification, and I-ADOPT Framework, enhancing interoperability and facilitating integration with other systems using these standards. The design of the ontology adheres to FAIR principles. It uses persistent identifiers, OWL2 for knowledge representation, semantic versioning, and rich metadata, including licensing and provenance details.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SPO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SPO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SPO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=SPO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SPO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SPO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SPO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/spo/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/spo/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"beta"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SPO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/GEO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/EARTH\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIODIV\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ENV\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Ilaria Rosati, Lucia Vaira]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/Parham.ramezani01\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":\"PR\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/Parham.ramezani01\",\"notation\":\"0009-0006-3432-6182\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0009-0006-3432-6182\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Parham Ramezani\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0dfa4930-953b-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0dfa4930-953b-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"parham.ramezani@lifewatch.eu\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SPO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#DescriptionLogics","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Protege\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":260.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":480},"SBTHES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/sandybeachthes/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SBTHES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/sandybeachthes/","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/EARTH\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"Ecologists, coastal scientists, citizen science iniatives, data producers on sandy beach studies, data scientist.","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Standardized terminology for describing both qualitative and quantitative variables crucial for characterizing sandy beach ecosystems.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Sandy Beach Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"LifeWatch Italy\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lifewatchitaly@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"28","omv:numberOfProperties":"13","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"308"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-03-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-03-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=SBTHES&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=SBTHES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"6","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"17"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/sandybeachthes/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/sandybeachthes/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/EARTH\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Senem Onen Tarantini, Lucia Fanini]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9157-1578\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9157-1578\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jessica Titocci\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4bd9e680-6787-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4bd9e680-6787-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"jessica.titocci@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-1749-2673\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-1749-2673\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Senem Onen Tarantini\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8cd4caf0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8cd4caf0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-2749-8588\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-2749-8588\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrea Tarallo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0587b410-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0587b410-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2301-2576\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2301-2576\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lucia Fanini\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ee9d9be0-dd8e-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ee9d9be0-dd8e-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0239-6849\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0239-6849\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Guilherme Corte\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b40fff10-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b40fff10-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5323-356X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5323-356X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jeffrey A. Sibaja-Cordero\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a2a1a750-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a2a1a750-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2184-9217\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2184-9217\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Thomas Schlacher\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/429dd430-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/429dd430-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Leonardo Lopes Costa\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/744b7900-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/744b7900-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8318-528X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8318-528X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Omar Defeo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3547a3c0-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3547a3c0-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4719-0481\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4719-0481\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Linda R. Harris\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/63d798d0-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/63d798d0-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Carlos Alberto de Moura Barboza\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d67e6520-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d67e6520-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0009-0001-9691-1989\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0009-0001-9691-1989\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martina Pulieri\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://link.springer.com/referencework/10.1007/1-4020-3880-1\",\"https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-102927-5.00016-3\",\"https://doi.org/10.1306/D4268EB9-2B26-11D7-8648000102C1865D\",\"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecss.2018.09.027\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"VocBench\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#IndexingTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#SearchTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":17.0,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":61.0,"normalizedScore":42,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":269.75,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":507},"ERITHES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/fae2-r561"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"ITINERIS Terminology Service\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ERITHES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"European","dct:audience":"Research Infrastructure Users; Research Infrastructure Managers","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/c_f788a36a","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"semantics@lifewatch.eu","dct:description":"The Environmental Research Infrastructures Thesaurus (ERITHES) was created within the task supporting semantic interoperability of the ITINERIS project (https://itineris.cnr.it). The Thesaurus was generated to provide controlled terms describing actors, ESFRI domains, facilities, services, research products and project management activities performed by Research Infrastructures.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21973\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO#ResearchInfrastructure\",\"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_vocab/atmosphere\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21921\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/30316\"]","dct:title":"Environmental Research Infrastructures Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"26","omv:numberOfProperties":"13","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"erithes","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"363"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/c_64ddaacf\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/c_5cbb458e\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/c_310e03fa\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/c_f788a36a\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/c_5e36951f\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/c_66874cbe\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-07-21T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2023-09-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ERITHES&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"2025-07-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ERITHES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/it, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"17"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":80.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/fae2-r561"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES?p=sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROSCIVOC, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EURIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROSCIVOC, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EURIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Ilaria Rosati"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-6800-951X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-6800-951X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Davide Raho\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/03b1fc90-4863-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/03b1fc90-4863-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"davide.raho@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3422-7230\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3422-7230\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ilaria Rosati\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4072-0662\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4072-0662\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cristina Di Muri\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/82dfd2e0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/82dfd2e0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"cristina.dimuri@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-1958-9412\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-1958-9412\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alexandra Nicoleta Muresan\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cdfd39d0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cdfd39d0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"alexandranicoleta.muresan@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0384-5490\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0384-5490\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gianmarco Ingrosso\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/787cdee0-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/787cdee0-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"gianmarco.ingrosso@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0009-0001-9691-1989\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0009-0001-9691-1989\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martina Pulieri\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-2914-2171\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-2914-2171\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gregorio Sgrigna\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c48b5c50-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c48b5c50-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"gregorio.sgrigna@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0468-1969\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0468-1969\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Enrica Nestola\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4a908710-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4a908710-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"enrica.nestola@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7895-0650\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7895-0650\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elena Partescano\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8e7ec1a0-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8e7ec1a0-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9d51a320-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9d51a320-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"epartescano@ogs.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-5360-0689\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-5360-0689\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Carmela Cornacchia\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/18321ce0-4871-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/18321ce0-4871-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/14db4e20-486f-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/14db4e20-486f-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"carmela.cornacchia@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Edoardo Di Russo\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6a33fbc0-4871-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6a33fbc0-4871-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/15b73300-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/15b73300-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"edoardo.dirusso@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adriana Mariotti\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c32240c0-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c32240c0-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2fa37c50-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2fa37c50-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"adriana.mariotti@cmcc.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simona Armeli Minicante\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/67c72090-3451-013c-2dad-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/67c72090-3451-013c-2dad-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"simona.armeli@ve.ismar.cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0009-0000-3109-9208\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0009-0000-3109-9208\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marco Pistillo\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/90b90260-4871-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/90b90260-4871-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f5df75f0-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f5df75f0-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"marco.pistillo@ingv.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8182-0454\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8182-0454\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marina Tumolo\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c6b02ec0-4871-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c6b02ec0-4871-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d4edf910-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d4edf910-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"marina.tumolo@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9361-8931\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9361-8931\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lucia Saganeiti\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ecbe7910-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ecbe7910-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lucia.saganeiti@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-2749-8588\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-2749-8588\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrea Tarallo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0587b410-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0587b410-dd8f-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7997-219X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7997-219X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alessandro Oggioni\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/244a9c20-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/244a9c20-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Caterina Bergami\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9b083630-0ebf-013c-7f2c-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9b083630-0ebf-013c-7f2c-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-6800-951X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-6800-951X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Davide Raho\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/03b1fc90-4863-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/03b1fc90-4863-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"davide.raho@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4072-0662\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4072-0662\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cristina Di Muri\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/82dfd2e0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/82dfd2e0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"cristina.dimuri@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-1958-9412\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-1958-9412\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alexandra Nicoleta Muresan\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cdfd39d0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cdfd39d0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"alexandranicoleta.muresan@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[\"Task 2.4 on Interdisciplinary Semantic Interoperability of the ITINERIS project\"]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-024-03185-4\",\"https://dx.doi.org/10.1504/IJMSO.2022.131133\",\"https://data.europa.eu/doi/10.2777/620649\",\"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoinf.2019.01.005\",\"https://roadmap2021.esfri.eu/\",\"https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-11821-1_4\",\" https://csrc.nist.gov/glossary/term/best_practice\",\"https://www.esfri.eu/glossary\",\"https://doi.org/10.1007/s13222-016-0231-8\",\"https://www.w3.org/TR/ld-glossary/#ontology\",\"https://doi.org/10.2777/8299402\",\"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3465752\",\"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2021/695/oj/eng\",\"https://doi.org/10.1007/s00799-005-0128-x\",\"https://doi.org/10.5334/dsj-2020-043\",\"https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-020-0486-7\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"VocBench\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#IntegrationTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#FilteringTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#SearchTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"ITINERIS\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5390f890-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5390f890-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://itineris.cnr.it\"}]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"ITINERIS\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5390f890-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5390f890-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://itineris.cnr.it\"}"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":304.75,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":960},"FAIR_VOCABULARY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/FAIR-Vocabulary"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/principles/index-en.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"FAIR_VOCABULARY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/FAIR","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"https://w3id.org/fair/principles/latest/A1","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This is the formal vocabulary (ontology) describing the FAIR principles.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/peta-pico/FAIR-nanopubs/refs/heads/master/principles.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"FAIR Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"5","omv:numberOfProperties":"1","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"fair","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"20"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/principles/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/FAIR-Principle-or-SubPrinciple\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/principles/index-en.html#http://semanticscience.org/resource/000090\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/principles/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/FAIR\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/principles/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/FAIR-SubPrinciple\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/principles/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/FAIR-Principle\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-12-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-12-10T18:00:10.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=FAIR_VOCABULARY&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=FAIR_VOCABULARY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/FAIR-Vocabulary","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/FAIR-Vocabulary"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.33,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.33,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Michel Dumontier, Tobias Kuhn]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4727-9435\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a9d871d0-b820-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a9d871d0-b820-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4727-9435\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4727-9435\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Michel Dumontier\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0fb124c0-8d46-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0fb124c0-8d46-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1267-0234\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/99dcdca0-2aae-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/99dcdca0-2aae-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-1267-0234\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-1267-0234\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tobias Kuhn\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0fca5120-8d46-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0fca5120-8d46-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"OWL API\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":269.33,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1425},"INSTRUMENT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontolog/instrument#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/instrument/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://linked.earth/ontology/#IntegrationTime","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"INSTRUMENT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://linked.earth/ontology/instrument#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://linked.earth/ontology/instrument/2.0.0/index-en.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://linked.earth/ontolog/instrument#AcceleratorMassSpectrometer","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Instrument Ontology defines the different types of instruments that can be used to measure in a paleo climate dataset.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://linked.earth/ontology/instrument/2.0.0/ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"The Linked Earth Instrument Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"30","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"le","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-12-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=INSTRUMENT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"\\r\\nCite as:\\r\\nhttp://earth.usc.edu/~khider/, http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5920-4751, http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/. The Linked Earth Instrument Ontology. Revision: 1.0.0. Retrieved from: http://linked.earth/ontology/instrument/1.0.0\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/INSTRUMENT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=INSTRUMENT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"28","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"5"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontolog/instrument#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontolog/instrument#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.5,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":53.5,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Deborah Khider"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paleoclimate Dynamics Laboratory\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5920-4751\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5920-4751\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julien Emile-Geay\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0454-7145\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0454-7145\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniel Garijo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c585eb70-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c585eb70-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yolanda Gil\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c567da50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c567da50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":271.5,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":559},"MARINETLO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ics.forth.gr/isl/ontology/MarineTLO/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://projects.ics.forth.gr/isl/MarineTLO/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MARINETLO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.ics.forth.gr/isl/ontology/MarineTLO/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://projects.ics.forth.gr/isl/MarineTLO/documentation/MarineTLO_documentation_v5.pdf","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://www.ics.forth.gr/isl/ontology/MarineTLO/BC10_Event","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MarineTLO is a top-level ontology for the marine domain (also applicable to the terrestrial domain).","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"MarineTLO Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"FORTH ICS\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e865b0f0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e865b0f0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.ics.forth.gr/isl\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"106","omv:numberOfProperties":"95","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"MarineTLO","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#UpperLevelOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"To tackle the need for having integrated sets of facts about marine species, and thus to assist research about species and biodiversity.\r\nIt provides a unified and coherent core model for schema mapping which enables formulating and answering queries which cannot be answered by any individual source.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2014-04-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-03437-9_29\",\"http://ercim-news.ercim.eu/en96/special/ontology-based-integration-of-heterogeneous-and-distributed-information-of-the-marine-domain\",\"http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/PROG-10-2014-0072\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=MARINETLO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"11","dct:modified":"2017-01-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/MARINETLO/download","foaf:logo":"https://assets.aims.fao.org/public/styles/full/public/MTLO.jpg?itok=ozb6o7Gl","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=MARINETLO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"6","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"13"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ics.forth.gr/isl/ontology/MarineTLO/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ics.forth.gr/isl/ontology/MarineTLO/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://virtuoso-catalogue.d4science.org/sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.75,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Yannis Tzitzikas"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2788-526X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2788-526X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pavlos Fafalios\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7f91c00-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7f91c00-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yannis Marketakis\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/716b0650-0e4a-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/716b0650-0e4a-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Chrysoula Bekiari \",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7c2d2e0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7c2d2e0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Carlo Allocca \",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7afd6c0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7afd6c0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8847-2130\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8847-2130\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yannis Tzitzikas\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e814afc0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e814afc0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Nikos Minadakis \",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7e600b0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7e600b0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Martin Doerr \",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7d5ea60-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7d5ea60-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2788-526X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2788-526X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pavlos Fafalios\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7f91c00-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7f91c00-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Julien Barde \",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e846dfa0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e846dfa0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yannis Marketakis\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/716b0650-0e4a-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/716b0650-0e4a-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Chrysoula Bekiari \",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7c2d2e0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7c2d2e0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Carlo Allocca \",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7afd6c0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7afd6c0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8847-2130\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8847-2130\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yannis Tzitzikas\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e814afc0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e814afc0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Nikos Minadakis \",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7e600b0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7e600b0-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Martin Doerr \",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7d5ea60-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e7d5ea60-9925-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"5.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[\" https://projects.ics.forth.gr/isl/MarineTLO/files/queries.html\"]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":55.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":274.75,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1226},"BIODIVTHES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/BLH"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"http://dx.doi.org/10.13143/lotr.4647"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/BLH/2.1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":87,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"Concepts and terms included in Biodiversity Thesaurus have been originally used to index the CNRS multilingual bibliographic database. The thesaurus has been developed for the purpose of homogenization and structuring of key-concepts of ecology and biodiversity within the framework of GDR SemanDiv (Research Group on Semantics of bioDiversity).\"]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.inist.fr","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIODIVTHES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"Ecology\",\"Environmental sciences\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/EnvEu_60\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20948\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/BLH-FHNG3BCR-H","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Biodiversity thesaurus\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This bilingual thesaurus organizes the key concepts of biodiversity sciences, in their basic and applied ecological components. It uses polyhierarchy and includes 818 reciprocal associative relationships. The 1654 French and English descriptors (designating 827 concepts) are enriched with a large number of synonyms (1860) and hidden variants (7020) in both languages. Concepts are grouped into 82 collections, by semantic categories, thematic fields and EBV classes (Essential Biodiversity Variables). Definitions are given with their sources. This resource is aligned with the international thesauri AGROVOC, GEMET (GEneral Multilingual Environmental Thesaurus) and EnvThes (Environmental Thesaurus), as well as with the ontology ENVO (Environment Ontology)., Ce thésaurus entièrement bilingue organise les concepts clés des sciences de la biodiversité, dans leurs composantes écologiques fondamentales et appliquées. Il utilise la polyhiérarchie et comprend 818 relations associatives réciproques. Les 1654 descripteurs français et anglais (désignant 827 concepts) sont accompagnés d'un grand nombre de synonymes (1860) et de variantes cachées (7020) dans les 2 langues. Les concepts sont regroupés en 82 collections, par catégories sémantiques, domaines thématiques et classes de VEB (variables essentielles de biodiversité). Les définitions sont données avec leurs sources. Cette ressource est alignée sur les thésaurus internationaux AGROVOC, GEMET (GEneral Multilingual Environmental Thesaurus) et EnvThes (Environmental Thesaurus), ainsi que sur l'ontologie ENVO (Environment Ontology).","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.biodivportal.gfbio.org/ontologies/BIODIVTHES/download?apikey=8d904e8e-41f9-454d-bbca-5184a9da4109","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Biodiversity Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"INIST\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"02mn0vt57\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:02mn0vt57\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institut de l'Information Scientifique et Technique\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b68a7ec0-0dfb-013c-7f10-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b68a7ec0-0dfb-013c-7f10-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"4","omv:numberOfProperties":"2","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"bdt","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"915"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2022-09-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2015-01-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02907484\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"null","schema:comment":"[\"This new edition 2.1 is the result of a complete revision of version 1.2. It has been enriched with 212 new concepts and 1000 new alternative terms, with a redesigned hierarchical structure, reducing the number of top level concepts by half. Alignments have been updated with AGROVOC (2022-02-01) and GEMET 4.2.3 (2021) versions, and performed with two new semantic resources: ENVTHES 3 (2020-07-03) and ENVO (2021-05-14).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2022-09-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"null","foaf:logo":"https://repository.ortolang.fr/api/thumbs/tbiodiversite/3/LogoOrtolang_Th%C3%A9saurus_Biodiversit%C3%A9.jpg?size=180","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"null","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/fra]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"4"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://bartoc.org, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://i-adopt.github.io/terminologies/, https://live.european-language-grid.eu/catalogue/lcr/13067, https://loterre.fr, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://www.ortolang.fr/market/terminologies/tbiodiversite, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://bartoc.org, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://i-adopt.github.io/terminologies/, https://live.european-language-grid.eu/catalogue/lcr/13067, https://loterre.fr, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://www.ortolang.fr/market/terminologies/tbiodiversite, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":10.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":94.0,"normalizedScore":83,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/BLH","dct:identifier":"http://dx.doi.org/10.13143/lotr.4647"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/BLH"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"null","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":90,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":90.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://www.eionet.europa.eu/gemet/, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/envo.owl, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://purl.org/iso25964/skos-thes#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.inist.fr/Ontology#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://creativecommons.org/ns#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"null","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"null","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/ontologies/BIODIVTHES/submissions/2","dct:subject":"[\"Ecology\",\"Environmental sciences\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/EnvEu_60\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20948\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"null","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://www.eionet.europa.eu/gemet/, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/envo.owl, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"null","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"null","mod:prefLabelProperty":"null","mod:authorProperty":"null","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":1.0,"normalizedScore":3,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Biodiversity Thesaurus Contact, Dominique Vachez]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"INIST\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"02mn0vt57\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:02mn0vt57\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institut de l'Information Scientifique et Technique\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b68a7ec0-0dfb-013c-7f10-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b68a7ec0-0dfb-013c-7f10-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dominique Vachez\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/731e2520-0dfd-013c-7f11-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/731e2520-0dfd-013c-7f11-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Isabelle Gomez\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"INIST\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"02mn0vt57\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:02mn0vt57\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institut de l'Information Scientifique et Technique\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b68a7ec0-0dfb-013c-7f10-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b68a7ec0-0dfb-013c-7f10-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fc8897d0-0dfd-013c-7f11-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fc8897d0-0dfd-013c-7f11-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Isabelle Gomez\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e2afcf30-8b0c-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e2afcf30-8b0c-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institute for scientific and technical information (Inist) - CNRS/UAR76\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e29750e0-8b0c-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e29750e0-8b0c-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dominique Vachez\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/731e2520-0dfd-013c-7f11-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/731e2520-0dfd-013c-7f11-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Isabelle Gomez\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"INIST\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"02mn0vt57\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:02mn0vt57\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institut de l'Information Scientifique et Technique\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b68a7ec0-0dfb-013c-7f10-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b68a7ec0-0dfb-013c-7f10-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fc8897d0-0dfd-013c-7f11-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fc8897d0-0dfd-013c-7f11-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/ontologies/BIODIVTHES/submissions/2","owl:versionInfo":"2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"VocBench\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#IntegrationTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#IndexingTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#MediationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":13.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":285.75,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1038},"I-ADOPT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/iadopt/ont"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/iadopt/ont/1.1.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"I-ADOPT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The I-ADOPT Framework is an ontology designed to facilitate interoperability between existing variable description models (including ontologies, taxonomy, and structured controlled vocabularies). One of the challenges in representing semantic descriptions of variables is getting people to agree about what they mean when describing the components that define the variables. The I-ADOPT ontology addresses this by providing core components and their relations that can be applied to define machine-interpretable variable descriptions that re-use FAIR vocabulary terms. It was developed by a core group of terminology experts and users from the Research Data Alliance (RDA) InteroperAble Descriptions of Observable Property Terminology (I-ADOPT) Working Group. The first published versions of the ontology up to v0.9.1 satisfied the basic cross-domain interoperability requirements. It defines four classes or \"concepts\" (Variable, Property, Entity, Constraint), and six object properties (hasProperty, hasObjectOfInterest, hasContextObject, hasMatrix, hasConstraint, constrains). The Variable is the top concept. It represents the description of something observed or mathematically derived. It minimally consists of one entity (the ObjectOfInterest) and its Property; a Property being a type of characteristic (i.e. a quantity or a quality). More complex variables can involve additional entities, for example an entity may have the role of Matrix and/or of ContextObject(s). The framework does not capture units, instruments, methods, and geographical location information; however its usage recommendation will make explicit reference to these by connecting the I-ADOPT framework to existing and complementary ontologies. This new version of the ontology (v1.0) adds one optional new class (VariableSet) and four optional new object properties (hasApplicableProperty, hasApplicableObjectOfInterest, hasApplicableMatrix, hasApplicableContextObject). This was necessary in order to enable flexibility in assigning optional and user-defined machine-interpretable categorizations of I-ADOPT variables under one or multiple coarser grouping concepts to facilitate dataset discovery and dataset aggregation. With the introduction of these concepts and properties, the framework enables different user communities or product developers to develop their own grouping criteria. While the Variable class must be connected to at least two classes via the mandatory properties hasProperty and hasObjectOIfInterest, the VariableSet class can have either of the new properties. Additionally, the VariableSet class can also be optionally connected to the Variable class using the property [ro:hasMember](http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/RO_0002351) from the [OBO Relations Ontology](https://obofoundry.org/ontology/ro.html).","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/i-adopt/ontology/main/ontology/i-adopt.ttl","omv:keywords":"[\"observable property\",\"variable\"]","dct:title":"I-ADOPT Framework ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"9","omv:numberOfProperties":"18","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[\"Variable\",\"Entity\",\"Property\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-05-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The I-ADOPT Framework ontology provides machine-readable variable descriptions in which the components are mapped to FAIR vocabulary terms.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-05-29T18:00:17.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.15497/RDA00071/2\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=I-ADOPT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=I-ADOPT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/iadopt/ont","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/iadopt/ont"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"local:local\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#OWL/XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Schema)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Schema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#OWL/XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Schema","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Barbara Magagna"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Barbara Magagna, GO FAIR Foundation, NL, ORCID: 0000-0003-2195-3997\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1d64c910-1ee5-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1d64c910-1ee5-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0964-4457\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0964-4457\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sirko Schindler\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/23e0fd30-5edf-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/23e0fd30-5edf-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"Sirko.Schindler@dlr.de\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-6612-3439\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-6612-3439\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maria Stoica\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ff094c40-5ede-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ff094c40-5ede-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c238a2d0-5ede-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c238a2d0-5ede-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"Maria.Stoica@colorado.edu\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-6559-4178\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-6559-4178\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gwenaëlle\\tMoncoiffé\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/56d07e90-5edd-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/56d07e90-5edd-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"gmon@noc.ac.uk\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Anusuriya Devaraju, Terrestrial Ecosystem Research Network (TERN), University of Queensland, Australia, ORCID: 0000-0003-0870-3192\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1d195fd0-1ee5-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1d195fd0-1ee5-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2195-3997\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2195-3997\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Barbara Magagna\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alison Pamment, National Centre for Atmospheric Science / Centre for Environmental Data Analysis, STFC Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, UK, ORCID: 0000-0001-5040-4626\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1cf88890-1ee5-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1cf88890-1ee5-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0870-3192\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0870-3192\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Anusuriya Devaraju\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/df978e50-5ede-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/df978e50-5ede-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7ff679f0-5ede-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7ff679f0-5ede-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"Anusuriya.Devaraju@csiro.au\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5040-4626\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5040-4626\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alison Pamment\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/655a5560-5edf-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/655a5560-5edf-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5c658b20-5edf-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5c658b20-5edf-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"alison.pamment@stfc.ac.uk\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-6122-9210\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-6122-9210\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Robert Huber\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b2702680-5f11-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b2702680-5f11-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"rhuber@uni-bremen.de\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-6875-5360\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-6875-5360\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Graybeal\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5fc46c90-5f11-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5fc46c90-5f11-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"jbgraybeal@sonic.net\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#DescriptionLogics","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Protege\",{\"mutex\":{},\"value\":\"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Protege\",\"hash\":-2355524085600621192,\"object\":null}]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#MethOntology"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":15.0,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":269.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1709},"ELTER_CL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/elter_cl/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/41bz-fd17"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"https://deims.org/\"]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ELTER_CL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/elter_cl/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"eLTER Controlled Lists\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"eLTER_CL is a thesaurus for controlled lists used by the eLTER community","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/LTER-Europe/eLTER_CL/main/elter_cl.ttl","omv:keywords":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21673\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21672\"]","dct:title":"eLTER Controlled Lists","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davide.raho\",\"notation\":\"00pggkr55\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:00pggkr55\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9562c3e0-5f02-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9562c3e0-5f02-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"info@ceh.ac.uk\",\"homepage\":\"https://www.ceh.ac.uk/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"32","omv:numberOfProperties":"11","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"CL","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"662"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-03-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-03-11T18:00:08.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ELTER_CL&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ELTER_CL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"32","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"27"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":80.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/elter_cl/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/41bz-fd17"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/elter_cl/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Barbara Magagna"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0655-3699\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0655-3699\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Christoph Wohner\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5a243d70-5ee0-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5a243d70-5ee0-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"christoph.wohner@umweltbundesamt.at\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0631-8231\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0631-8231\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Johannes Peterseil\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/07e65e20-0e3e-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/07e65e20-0e3e-013c-7f17-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2195-3997\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2195-3997\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Barbara Magagna\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-6968-8275\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-6968-8275\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Juliana da Silva Menger\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b1cd7650-5ee0-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b1cd7650-5ee0-013c-89c0-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"j.menger@ufz.de\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2195-3997\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2195-3997\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Barbara Magagna\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"http://purl.org/cld/freq/irregular"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"eLTER\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Integrated European Long-Term Ecosystem, critical zone and socio-ecological Research\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/feebab20-0ef4-013c-a970-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/feebab20-0ef4-013c-a970-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":15.0,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/eLTER+PLUS, name=Integrated European Long-Term Ecosystem, critical zone and socio-ecological Research infrastructure Advanced Community project, updated=2023-04-18T18:07:14.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL], acronym=eLTER PLUS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/mabablue], created=2023-04-18T18:07:14.000+00:00, homePage=https://elter-ri.eu/elter-plus, contacts=Michael Mirtl, michael.mirtl@ufz.de , description=eLTER PLUS connects major scientific user communities with the site networks and its data/services, works on detailed site and observation specifications and pilots the technical service development, institution=University of Helsinki, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/eLTER+PLUS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":280.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":931},"PHYTOVRE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrephytoplankton/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/mgab-hx73"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PHYTOVRE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrephytoplankton/","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/10023\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/c_8f5c8ec3\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"Researchers, students, data managers, data stewards, and technicians working with virtual research environments related to phytoplankton.","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrephytoplankton/c_b89cdbfb","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"PHYTOPLANTKON VRE\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Phytoplankton VRE\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Phytoplankton VRE Thesaurus includes a set of concepts designed to facilitate navigation and use of the Virtual Research Environment (VRE), and to support data harmonisation and interoperability within the VRE, as well as data comparability and reusability across different platforms and research communities.\r\nIn particular, the thesaurus encompasses concepts related to phytoplankton counting methods, statistical analyses, community indices, and parameters used in the VRE. It also includes standardised terms required to harmonise data templates used as input files for the VRE, the complete list of services available within the VRE, and specific terminology related to phytoplankton.\r\nThe Phytoplankton VRE Thesaurus is aligned with existing vocabularies and thesauri to ensure semantic consistency and interoperability across research infrastructures, including the Traits Thesaurus, the Biomass VRE Thesaurus, and other relevant domain-specific semantic artefacts.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Phytoplankton VRE Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"26","omv:numberOfProperties":"14","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"vrephytoplankton","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"456"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrephytoplankton/c_e5beafd1\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrephytoplankton/c_83d9e97e\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrephytoplankton/c_d3d62c64\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrephytoplankton/c_cd8aebf8\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-01-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-01-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[\"2025-11-09T00:00:00.000+00:00\",\"2026-01-16T00:00:00.000+00:00\"]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PHYTOVRE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PHYTOVRE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"17"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":80.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrephytoplankton/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/mgab-hx73"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/vrephytoplankton/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE?p=sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.org/dc/terms/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":13.75,"normalizedScore":42,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.org/dc/terms/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/10023\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/erithes/c_8f5c8ec3\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Jessica Titocci, Alberto Basset, Teodoro Semeraro]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9157-1578\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9157-1578\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jessica Titocci\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4bd9e680-6787-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4bd9e680-6787-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"jessica.titocci@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9239-9060\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9239-9060\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Teodoro Semeraro\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/80b2ab90-d8d9-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/80b2ab90-d8d9-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"teodoro.semeraro@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0384-5490\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0384-5490\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gianmarco Ingrosso\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/787cdee0-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/787cdee0-486e-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"gianmarco.ingrosso@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9709-6114\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9709-6114\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Francesco De Leo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d7dbec40-d8d9-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d7dbec40-d8d9-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"francesco.deleo@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0009-0001-9691-1989\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0009-0001-9691-1989\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martina Pulieri\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0409-2286\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0409-2286\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lorenzo\\tLiberatore\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/037dcad0-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/037dcad0-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lorenzo.liberatore@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[\"The Phytoplankton VRE Thesaurus was generated as part of the activities of work packages 6 and 8 of the ITINERIS project.\"]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOVRE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"Logic-based","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"VocBench\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"ITINERIS\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5390f890-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5390f890-486d-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://itineris.cnr.it\"}]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":63.0,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":302.75,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":835},"NANO_SUPERSEDED":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/np/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NANO_SUPERSEDED","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/OTHER\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"superseded nanopub","omv:resourceLocator":"https://np.knowledgepixels.com/RAmgOfh39hptxRhMh68UHIj8n3NfEb-EB4_gR8UMy7dEc.trig.txt","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Superseded Nanopub","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"5","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO_SUPERSEDED/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-04-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-04-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=NANO_SUPERSEDED&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO_SUPERSEDED/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO_SUPERSEDED/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO_SUPERSEDED/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=NANO_SUPERSEDED&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"5","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO_SUPERSEDED/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO_SUPERSEDED/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO_SUPERSEDED","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"5"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/np/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/np/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO_SUPERSEDED/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/OTHER\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Martina Pulieri"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANO_SUPERSEDED/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":218.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1392},"ACFORMAT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ACFORMAT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Controlled Vocabulary for Dublin Core format\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Audubon Core borrows the Dublin Core terms dc:format and dcterms:format to provide information about the physical or electronic format of a media item. This controlled vocabulary provides values for those two terms., Controlled values list for Dublin Core format","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Applications\",\"Formats\",\"Models\"]","dct:title":"Audubon Core Controlled Vocabulary for Dublin Core format","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"TDWG\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Biodiversity Information Standards\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/35835710-b9cf-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/35835710-b9cf-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"secretary@tdwg.org\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"acformat","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACFORMAT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"122"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m007\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m045\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e011\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m047\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m009\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e029\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m038\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e038\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m063\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e041\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m021\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m023\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m061\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m025\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e027\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e023\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e012\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m030\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m070\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e014\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m032\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e025\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e016\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m034\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m072\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e018\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e001\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m036\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m037\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m039\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e003\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m026\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e046\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m064\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m010\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e008\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m066\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m028\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e010\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m068\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e019\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e042\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e006\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m024\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e044\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m062\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e002\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m020\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e040\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m060\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m065\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m011\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e031\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e004\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m022\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m013\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m067\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m051\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m029\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m053\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m015\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m069\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m027\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e013\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e015\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e017\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m005\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m043\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e007\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e034\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e045\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e036\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m054\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e047\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m016\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e009\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m018\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e021\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m056\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m003\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m058\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m041\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m059\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m001\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e043\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e005\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m048\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e030\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e048\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m012\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e032\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m050\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m014\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m019\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m052\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m057\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m055\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m017\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e028\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m004\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m031\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e024\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m042\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m033\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m006\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e026\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m044\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m071\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m046\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m035\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m008\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m049\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e033\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e035\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e037\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e020\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e022\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m040\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e039\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m002\"]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-03-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-10-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://ac.tdwg.org/format/\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ACFORMAT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Controlled values list for Dublin Core format\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACFORMAT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACFORMAT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACFORMAT/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ACFORMAT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACFORMAT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACFORMAT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACFORMAT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m007\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m045\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e011\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m047\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m009\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e029\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m038\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e038\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m063\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e041\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m021\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m023\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m061\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m025\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e027\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e023\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e012\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m030\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m070\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e014\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m032\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e025\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e016\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m034\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m072\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e018\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e001\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m036\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m037\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m039\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e003\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m026\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e046\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m064\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m010\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e008\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m066\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m028\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e010\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m068\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e019\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e042\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e006\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m024\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e044\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m062\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e002\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m020\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e040\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m060\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m065\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m011\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e031\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e004\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m022\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m013\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m067\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m051\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m029\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m053\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m015\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m069\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m027\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e013\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e015\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e017\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m005\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m043\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e007\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e034\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e045\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e036\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m054\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e047\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m016\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e009\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m018\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e021\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m056\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m003\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m058\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m041\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m059\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m001\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e043\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e005\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m048\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e030\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e048\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m012\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e032\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m050\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m014\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m019\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m052\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m057\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m055\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m017\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e028\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m004\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m031\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e024\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m042\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m033\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m006\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e026\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m044\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m071\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m046\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m035\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m008\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m049\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e033\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e035\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e037\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e020\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e022\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m040\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/e039\",\"http://rs.tdwg.org/format/values/m002\"]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACFORMAT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Steve Baskauf, Ed Baker]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4365-3135\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4365-3135\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Steve Baskauf\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b429020-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b429020-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0623-6682\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0623-6682\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Matthew Blissett\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/225874f0-b9d0-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/225874f0-b9d0-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"mblissett@gbif.org\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Douglas Boyer\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5e68a9e0-b9d0-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/5e68a9e0-b9d0-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"doug.boyer@duke.edu\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACFORMAT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2020-10-13"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":855},"DSW":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/dsw/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/y2n5-pr31"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"A goal in the creation of DSW was to facilitate consistent markup of biodiversity data so that RDF graphs created by different providers could be easily merged. Accordingly, DSW provides a mechanism for testing whether its terms are being used in a manner consistent with its model. Two transitive object properties enable the creation of simple SPARQL queries that can be used to discover new information about linked resources whose metadata are generated by different providers.\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/darwin-sw/dsw","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DSW","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/darwin-sw/dsw/wiki","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/darwin-sw/dsw/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Darwin-SW\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Version 0.4 to 1.0 fixed reversed dsw:locates and dsw:locatedAt. Added labels. Changed comments and descriptions to conform to DC and DwC precedent. Added subClassOf relations to RO hasEvidence and isEvidenceFor. Specified preferred direction for inverse object property pairs., Changes from version 0.2.1 to version 0.3: removal of all functional and inverse function properties of object property terms, use of dwctype classes, deprecation of terms replaced by dwciri: terms, removal of references to TDWG Ontology., Changes from version 0.3 to 0.4 change DwC class namespace from dwctype: to dwc: to follow class proposal, removed references to TDWG TaxonConcept ontology; deprecated terms that now have equivalent terms in Darwin Core., Change from version 1.0 to 1.0.1 Add CC0 license., Version 0.4 to 1.0 fixed reversed dsw:locates and dsw:locatedAt. Added labels. Changed comments and descriptions to conform to DC and DwC precedent.  Added subClassOf relations to RO hasEvidence and isEvidenceFor.  Specified preferred direction for inverse object property pairs.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/darwin-sw/dsw/master/dsw.owl","omv:keywords":"[\"Ecological phenomena\",\"Biodiversity\",\"Observations\"]","dct:title":"Darwin-SW","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/darwin-sw/dsw"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"19","omv:numberOfProperties":"28","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dsw","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"DSW is based on a model derived from a community discussion about the relationships among the main Darwin Core classes. DSW creates a new class to accommodate an important aspect of its model that is not currently part of Darwin Core: a class of Tokens, which are forms of evidence. DSW uses Web Ontology Language (OWL) to make assertions about the classes in its model and to define object properties that are used to link instances of those classes.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-02-13T18:00:07.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://www.semantic-web-journal.net/content/darwin-sw-darwin-core-based-terms-expressing-biodiversity-data-rdf-1\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[\"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/darwin-sw/dsw/master/img/dsw-1-0-graph-model.png\"]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=DSW&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Darwin Semantic Web, version 1.0.1 . Please see https://github.com/darwin-sw/ for full details\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/DSW/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=DSW&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"5","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"12"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":84.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/dsw/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/y2n5-pr31"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/dsw/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW?p=sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW/submissions/1","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#comment","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#comment","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Steve Baskauf"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-1031-3249\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-1031-3249\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Campbell Webb\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b66a880-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b66a880-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4365-3135\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4365-3135\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Steve Baskauf\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b429020-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8b429020-0e46-013c-7f1f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DSW/submissions/1","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"OWL API\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":284.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1606},"ECSO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.dataone.org/odo/ECSO8.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.dataone.org/odo/ECSO8.owl/0.10.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"Artic Data Center\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ECSO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ECSO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Environmental_Sciences\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Earth_Sciences\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"Researchers, Data managers","foaf:page":"https://github.com/DataONEorg/sem-prov-ontologies/tree/main/observation","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/DataONEorg/sem-prov-ontologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"https://arcticdata.io/catalog/view/doi%3A10.18739%2FA20Z70Z1H\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"DataONE ontology of Carbon Flux measurements for MsTMIP and LTER Use Cases","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/DataONEorg/sem-prov-ontologies/refs/heads/main/ecso/ECSO8.owl","omv:keywords":"[\"Earth science\",\"Ecosystem science\",\"Ecosystem\",\"Ontology\"]","dct:title":"The Ecosystem Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/DataONEorg/sem-prov-ontologies/tree/ECSO8-add_non-carbon_measurements"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2102","omv:numberOfProperties":"122","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ecso","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"18"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-09T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"ECSO expresses 'Measurement Types' to describe measurements present in raw data. It uses the OBOÉ observation and measurements design pattern (OBOE: https://github.com/NCEAS/oboe) to capture both the 'entity of interest' and 'characteristic measured'. ECSO is intended to be used with terms in other OWL ontologies, including ENVO, PATO, CHEBI, BCO and PCO. It is currently focused on carbon and associated measurements.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"10","dct:created":"2024-12-09T18:00:23.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ECSO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"204","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ECSO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1642","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"121"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://aber-owl.net, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://aber-owl.net, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":10.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":88.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.dataone.org/odo/ECSO8.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.dataone.org/odo/ECSO8.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu/ontologies/ECSO?p=sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"beta"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Environmental_Sciences\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Earth_Sciences\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Bryce Mecum"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0632-7576\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0632-7576\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mark Schildhauer\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/83ca92e0-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/83ca92e0-fe2d-013c-34b6-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"schild@nceas.ucsb.edu\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.10.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":52.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":292.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1380},"LUPO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LUPO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"LifeWatch ERIC Upper Ontology \"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The LifeWatch ERIC Upper Ontology (LUPO) is the model defining the core set of LifeWatch ERIC elements (Actors, Services and Infrastructure) and describing their high-level arrangement. LUPO is extendable and will foster, connect and describe lower level models of its core elements, with the vision to provide functionalities that facilitate the uptake, re-use and enrichment of LifeWatch ERIC resources by an ever broader community.\r\n","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"LifeWatch ERIC Upper Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"LifeWatch ERIC\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/deb42190-0ec1-013c-7f2f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/deb42190-0ec1-013c-7f2f-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"16","omv:numberOfProperties":"23","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2021-04-07T02:19:20.000-07:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-04-07T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"null","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"3","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"null","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"null","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"10"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"null","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":90,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":90.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/description","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/description","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Xeni Kechagioglou, Nicola Fiore, Ilaria Rosati, Lucia Vaira]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-7819-5416\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-7819-5416\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ismael Navas-Delgado\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/646848d0-0e49-013c-7f21-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/646848d0-0e49-013c-7f21-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jose Aldana\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/86eb4220-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/86eb4220-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Josem Avila\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d14eb8e0-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d14eb8e0-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Francisco Manuel Sanchez Cano\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bf051db0-0e49-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bf051db0-0e49-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yannis Marketakis\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/716b0650-0e4a-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/716b0650-0e4a-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cristóbal Barba\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/477b5960-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/477b5960-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-9538-2966\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-9538-2966\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nicola Fiore\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bef355f0-0e49-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bef355f0-0e49-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"nicola.fiore@equiup.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Xeni Kechagioglou\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ecbaef50-0e46-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ecbaef50-0e46-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2985-3480\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2985-3480\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"José Manuel García-Nieto\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7d770b20-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7d770b20-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-5935-6074\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-5935-6074\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lucia Vaira\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9fdab880-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9fdab880-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\" 0000-0002-0303-2740\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maria del Mar Roldan\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/06bf1780-0e47-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/06bf1780-0e47-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/06ce56a0-0e47-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/06ce56a0-0e47-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-6717-9418\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-6717-9418\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Zhiming Zhao\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2b1c1730-0e47-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2b1c1730-0e47-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nikos Minadakis\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9fb7b7e0-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9fb7b7e0-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3422-7230\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3422-7230\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ilaria Rosati\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bart Vanhoorne\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0496vr396\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:0496vr396\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Flanders Marine Institute\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/41331060-0e47-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/41331060-0e47-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d1062980-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d1062980-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Matej Krebelj\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9fecdeb0-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9fecdeb0-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9141-4409\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9141-4409\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Antoni Huguet\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d12a08c0-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d12a08c0-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Xiaofeng Liao\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6d2d0950-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6d2d0950-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Antonio José Sáenz Albanés\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d13cf480-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d13cf480-0e4b-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LUPO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0 2021/04/07"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":609},"STY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.bioontology.org/ontology/STY"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://lhncbc.nlm.nih.gov/semanticnetwork/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"STY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK9679/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://purl.bioontology.org/ontology/STY/T057","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"http://purl.bioontology.org/ontology/STY/T057\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Semantic Network consists of (1) a set of broad subject categories, or Semantic Types, that provide a consistent categorization of all concepts represented in the UMLS Metathesaurus, and (2) a set of useful and important relationships, or Semantic Relations, that exist between Semantic Types. This section of the documentation provides an overview of the Semantic Network, and describes the files of the Semantic Network. Sample records illustrate structure and content of these files.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/STY/download?apikey=e21d54dd-a4c7-4cdb-a53f-0e6a93bcc8d6","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"UMLS Semantic Network","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"127","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"sty","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/STY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#ApplicationOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2023-09-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"At the US National Library of Medicine we have developed the Unified Medical Language System (UMLS), whose goal it is to provide integrated access to a large number of biomedical resources by unifying the vocabularies that are used to access those resources. The UMLS currently inter-relates some 60 controlled vocabularies in the biomedical domain. The UMLS coverage is quite extensive, including not only many concepts in clinical medicine, but also a large number of concepts applicable to the broad domain of the life sciences. In order to provide an overarching conceptual framework for all UMLS concepts, we developed an upper-level ontology, called the UMLS semantic network. The semantic network, through its 134 semantic types, provides a consistent categorization of all concepts represented in the UMLS. The 54 links between the semantic types provide the structure for the network and represent important relationships in the biomedical domain. Because of the growing number of information resources that contain genetic information, the UMLS coverage in this area is being expanded. We recently integrated the taxonomy of organisms developed by the NLM's National Center for Biotechnology Information, and we are currently working together with the developers of the Gene Ontology to integrate this resource, as well. As additional, standard, ontologies become publicly available, we expect to integrate these into the UMLS construct.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2015-12-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1002/cfg.255\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=STY&q=","schema:comment":"[\"No change inn v12, since 2015AA.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/STY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/STY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"12","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/ontologies/STY/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=STY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"127","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/STY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/STY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/STY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"9"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://aber-owl.net, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://vest.agrisemantics.org, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://aber-owl.net, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://vest.agrisemantics.org, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":12.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":81.0,"normalizedScore":71,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.bioontology.org/ontology/STY","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.bioontology.org/ontology/STY"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"local:local\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"UMLS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"UMLS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#semantic_network)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#semantic_network"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":10.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/STY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#semantic_network","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":17.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Syphax  Bouazzouni, Olivier Bodenreider]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-2404-1582\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-2404-1582\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Clement Jonquet\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cf5d3b20-03d6-013d-348d-000c2996c7af\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cf5d3b20-03d6-013d-348d-000c2996c7af\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://lhncbc.nlm.nih.gov/semanticnetwork/\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/STY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"NLM\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"U.S. National Library of Medicine\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a275b2b0-b4ab-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a275b2b0-b4ab-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":244.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":740},"SCAR_CGA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.aad.gov.au/aadc/gaz/scar/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SCAR_CGA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/GEO\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Collated by Programma Nazionale di Ricerche in Antartide (Italy) in the framework of the SCAR Standing Committee on Antarctic Geographic Information (SCAGI)., Collated by Programma Nazionale di Ricerche in Antartide (Italy) in the framework of the SCAR Standing Committee on Antarctic Geographic Information (SCAGI)","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SCAR Gazetteer of Antarctica","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SCAR_CGA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"39006"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-11-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-09-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=SCAR_CGA&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SCAR_CGA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SCAR_CGA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/SCAR_CGA/download","foaf:logo":"https://data.aad.gov.au/aadc/gaz/scar/assets/scar_logo_sm.gif","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=SCAR_CGA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SCAR_CGA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SCAR_CGA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SCAR_CGA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.aad.gov.au/aadc/gaz/scar/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.aad.gov.au/aadc/gaz/scar/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#gazetteer)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#gazetteer"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SCAR_CGA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/GEO\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#gazetteer","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Carlo Baroni"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SCAR_CGA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":229.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3918},"ESMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/esmo.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/fq9j-1r86"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/FlavAff/ESMOntology/tree/main","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ESMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20520\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21334\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"Scientists or practitioners in the ecosystem services monitoring field","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Ecosystem Services Monitoring Ontology systematises the language of ecosystem services across major conceptual frameworks advancing conceptual clarity and operationalisation of ecosystem services.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/FlavAff/ESMOntology/refs/heads/main/Code/ESMOdata.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"The Ecosystem Services Monitoring Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/FlavAff/ESMOntology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"119","omv:numberOfProperties":"71","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ESMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"155"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-07-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-07-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoser.2025.101726\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[\"https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S2212041625000300-gr2_lrg.jpg\"]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ESMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ESMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ESMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"23","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ESMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ESMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"7","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ESMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ESMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ESMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":79.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/esmo.owl","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/fq9j-1r86"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/esmo.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ESMO?p=sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ESMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20520\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21334\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.75,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Flavio Affinito"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Flavio Affinito\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/44bc85a0-4ea4-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/44bc85a0-4ea4-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ESMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"Protégé\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":282.75,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1713},"AGROVOC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"https://www.fao.org/publications/\",\"https://cgspace.cgiar.org/\",\"https://datenzentrum.bonares.de/research-data.php\",\"https://mel.cgiar.org/\",\"http://www.fao.org/agris/\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://agrovoc.fao.org/browse/agrovoc/en/","void:uriRegexPattern":"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_","omv:acronym":"AGROVOC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/","dct:subject":"[\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Fishery\",\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Forestry\",\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Environment\",\"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_3055\",\"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_49892\",\"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_2934\",\"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_2593\",\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Agriculture\",\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Food\",\"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_203\",\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Nutrition\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"Worldwide","foaf:page":"https://www.fao.org/agrovoc/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_38445","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"AGROVOC\"]","doap:mailing-list":"https://dgroups.org/fao/agrovoc/join","dct:description":"AGROVOC is a multilingual, multidisciplinary thesaurus covering the activities of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the UN. AGROVOC covers all areas of interest to FAO, such as food, nutrition, agriculture, forestry, fisheries, names of animals and plants, environment, biological notions, techniques of plant cultivation, etc. It is coordinated by FAO, with a network of institutions responsible for the different language versions and domains. As of March 2024, AGROVOC consists of +41 000 concepts and +1 145 000 terms in up to 42 languages.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"AGROVOC","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"FAO\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"00pe0tf51\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:00pe0tf51\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/536a64d0-0ec1-013c-7f2e-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/536a64d0-0ec1-013c-7f2e-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"34","omv:numberOfProperties":"209","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"agrovoc","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"1238700"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-06-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"AGROVOC is a multilingual, multidisciplinary thesaurus covering the activities of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the UN. AGROVOC covers all areas of interest to FAO, such as food, nutrition, agriculture, forestry, fisheries, names of animals and plants, environment, biological notions, techniques of plant cultivation, etc. It is coordinated by FAO, with a network of institutions responsible for the different language versions and domains. As of March 2024, AGROVOC consists of +41 000 concepts and +1 145 000 terms in up to 42 languages.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-06-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://www.fao.org/agrovoc/publications\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=AGROVOC&q=","schema:comment":"[\"http://www.fao.org/agrovoc/news\\r\\nSince the early 1980's, the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) has coordinated AGROVOC, a multilingual and controlled vocabulary which is a valuable tool for data to be classified homogeneously, facilitating interoperability and reuse.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"4","dct:modified":"2023-12-01T17:27:42.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/AGROVOC/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=AGROVOC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"7","schema:associatedMedia":"[\"https://www.fao.org/agrovoc/news/\"]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/hi, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/de, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/ar, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/ja, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/es, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/zh, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/nl, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/pt, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/it, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/el, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fi]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[\"To curate and add new concepts to the thesaurus. Translating and localizing the vocabulary content to as many languages as needed. Encourage use of AGROVOC to index and tag information resources for subsequent data retrieval. http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/\"]","mod:maxChildCount":"22"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://bartoc.org, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://lod-cloud.net/dataset/agrovoc, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://fairsharing.org, https://vocabs.ardc.edu.au]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://bartoc.org, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://lod-cloud.net/dataset/agrovoc, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://fairsharing.org, https://vocabs.ardc.edu.au]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":10.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":79.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://agrovoc.fao.org/sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrontology, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2008/05/skos-xl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://vocabularies.unesco.org/, https://www.wikidata.org/, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEMET, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ANAEETHES, http://id.loc.gov/authorities/sh90003079#concept, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SDGIO, http://lod.gesis.org/thesoz/concept/q, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NALT, https://portal.dnb.de/, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CABT, http://www.gesis.org/en/services/tools-standards/social-science-thesaurus/, https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/EUROVOC, https://ukat.aim25.com/thesaurus/concept/, http://www.cadastralvocabulary.org/, http://metadata.un.org/, http://crai.ub.edu/, http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/, https://icd.who.int/icdapi, http://zbw.eu/stw/versions/latest/about, http://dbpedia.org/void/Dataset, http://www.geonames.org/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrontology, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2008/05/skos-xl]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Fishery\",\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Forestry\",\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Environment\",\"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_3055\",\"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_49892\",\"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_2934\",\"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_2593\",\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Agriculture\",\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Food\",\"http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_203\",\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Nutrition\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://vocabularies.unesco.org/, https://www.wikidata.org/, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEMET, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ANAEETHES, http://id.loc.gov/authorities/sh90003079#concept, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SDGIO, http://lod.gesis.org/thesoz/concept/q, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NALT, https://portal.dnb.de/, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CABT, http://www.gesis.org/en/services/tools-standards/social-science-thesaurus/, https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/EUROVOC, https://ukat.aim25.com/thesaurus/concept/, http://www.cadastralvocabulary.org/, http://metadata.un.org/, http://crai.ub.edu/, http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/, https://icd.who.int/icdapi, http://zbw.eu/stw/versions/latest/about, http://dbpedia.org/void/Dataset, http://www.geonames.org/]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":52.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"https://www.fao.org/documents/card/en/c/cb2838en","dct:rightsHolder":"AGROVOC Team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":91,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"FAO\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"00pe0tf51\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:00pe0tf51\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/536a64d0-0ec1-013c-7f2e-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/536a64d0-0ec1-013c-7f2e-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"http://purl.org/cld/freq/monthly"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGROVOC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2024-04"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"VocBench\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#IndexingTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":13.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":61.0,"normalizedScore":42,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":290.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":543},"EURIO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.europa.eu/s66#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://data.europa.eu/s66/v1.1#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://op.europa.eu/en/web/eu-vocabularies/dataset/-/resource?uri=http://publications.europa.eu/resource/dataset/eurio","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EURIO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://op.europa.eu/en/web/eu-vocabularies/dataset/-/resource?uri=http://publications.europa.eu/resource/dataset/eurio","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"EUropean Research Information Ontology\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"EURIO (EUropean Research Information Ontology) conceptualises, formally encodes and makes available in an open, structured and machine-readable format data about resarch projects funded by the EU's framework programmes for research and innovation., The EUropean Research Information Ontology (EURIO) conceptualises","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"eurio","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"016jmhr98\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:016jmhr98\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Publications Office of the European Union\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b9686820-0eba-013c-7f25-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b9686820-0eba-013c-7f25-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"50","omv:numberOfProperties":"109","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EURIO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2021-12-06T06:13:18.000-08:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2021-10-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://op.europa.eu/en/web/eu-vocabularies/dataset/-/resource?uri=http://publications.europa.eu/resource/dataset/eurio\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"null","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EURIO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EURIO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2021-08-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"null","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"null","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"23","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EURIO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EURIO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EURIO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"34"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":74.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.europa.eu/s66#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.europa.eu/s66#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"null","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":90,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":90.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EURIO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#comment","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#comment","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Publications Office of the European Union"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EURIO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1 - 15 October 2021"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":476},"TRAITS_THES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/traits/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/sa6p-ta25"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW%20ITA%20Data%20Portal\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"TRAITS_THES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/traits/","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/10023\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"Researchers, students, data managers and technicians working with traits information on aquatic organisms.","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/traits/c_f48230fb","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Traits Thesaurus is a comprehensive semantic resource developed to standardise trait data and metadata for aquatic organisms. It is the result of the revision and integration of the Phytoplankton, Zooplankton, Fish, Macroalgae and Macrozoobenthos Traits Thesauri, originally developed by LifeWatch Italy, into a unique and unified thesaurus. The Traits Thesaurus has been achieved through a combination of manual and automated alignment processes.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Traits Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"LifeWatch Italy\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lifewatchitaly@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"26","omv:numberOfProperties":"13","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"1620"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/FISHTRAITS\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS\"]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-12-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-11-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=TRAITS_THES&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The integration of the LifeWatch Italy Traits Thesauri was achieved through a combination of manual and automated alignment efforts conducted within the Biodiversity Track of the 2023 OAEI (Ontology Alignment Evaluation Initiative). Automated alignments were performed using the LogMap, LogMapLt, LogMapKG, Matcha and OLaLa ontology alignment systems to ensure accurate and efficient mapping between the thesauri.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"2025-12-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/TRAITS_THES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=TRAITS_THES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"17"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":79.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/traits/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/sa6p-ta25"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/traits/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES?p=sparql\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS, https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/FISHTRAITS, https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS, https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS\"]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/FISHTRAITS\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS\"]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FISHTRAITS\"]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/10023\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS, https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/FISHTRAITS, https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS, https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":52.75,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Jessica Titocci, Ilaria Rosati, Martina Pulieri]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0009-0001-9691-1989\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0009-0001-9691-1989\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martina Pulieri\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/746cffc0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9157-1578\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9157-1578\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jessica Titocci\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4bd9e680-6787-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4bd9e680-6787-013d-b706-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"jessica.titocci@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-4227-6377\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-4227-6377\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Angela Carluccio\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9c9c5c50-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9c9c5c50-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-1749-2673\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-1749-2673\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Senem Onen Tarantini\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8cd4caf0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8cd4caf0-8fb3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7205-3940\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7205-3940\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elena Stanca\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/84d4fbd0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/84d4fbd0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7346-6675\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7346-6675\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alessandra Pugnetti\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cd15f820-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cd15f820-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simona Armeli Minicante\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/67c72090-3451-013c-2dad-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/67c72090-3451-013c-2dad-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"simona.armeli@ve.ismar.cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Claudia Miglietta\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f9293260-0e41-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f9293260-0e41-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3422-7230\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3422-7230\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ilaria Rosati\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7534-3126\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7534-3126\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Angela Boggero\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd4b8d30-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd4b8d30-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0261-313X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0261-313X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paolo Tagliolato\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/95c13e40-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/95c13e40-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7997-219X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7997-219X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alessandro Oggioni\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/244a9c20-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/244a9c20-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0002-9415\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0002-9415\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Leonilde Roselli\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dbeed5e0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dbeed5e0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5946-6532\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5946-6532\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adriana Zingone\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bc9952a0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bc9952a0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Caterina Bergami\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9b083630-0ebf-013c-7f2c-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9b083630-0ebf-013c-7f2c-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Angel Pérez-Ruzafa\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ff620e10-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ff620e10-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julia Polo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dc8fdeb0-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dc8fdeb0-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4358-5478\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4358-5478\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sarah Hasnain\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2076f620-87f3-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2076f620-87f3-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Antonella Petrocelli\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/318afe80-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/318afe80-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3170-0774\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3170-0774\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fabio  Cianferoni\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd06db10-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd06db10-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"fabio.cianferoni@unifi.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Emanuele Mancini\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bca70e90-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bca70e90-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tiziana Durazzano\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a8fe97b0-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a8fe97b0-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Diego Fontaneto\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e37319f0-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e37319f0-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lyudmila Todorova Kambuska\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2b404670-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2b404670-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stefanie Dekeyzer\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dfdd73f0-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dfdd73f0-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Antonella Bottalico\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/410840d0-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/410840d0-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Patrick Pata\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b5cf9430-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b5cf9430-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4072-0662\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4072-0662\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cristina Di Muri\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/82dfd2e0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/82dfd2e0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"cristina.dimuri@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Silvia Pulina\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c19c6520-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c19c6520-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marjohn Baludo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d7a27b30-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d7a27b30-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Letizia Sion\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3af01790-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3af01790-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0409-2286\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0409-2286\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lorenzo\\tLiberatore\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/037dcad0-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/037dcad0-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lorenzo.liberatore@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tiziana Di Lorenzo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/efe3d1d0-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/efe3d1d0-7f34-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Roberta\\tPiscia\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/07eb6b50-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/07eb6b50-7f35-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-1958-9412\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-1958-9412\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alexandra Nicoleta Muresan\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CNR-IRET\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Research Council of Italy, Research Institute on Terrestrial Ecosystems\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0afeff90-4870-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.iret.cnr.it\"}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cdfd39d0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cdfd39d0-4862-013e-9ce9-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"alexandranicoleta.muresan@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"VocBench\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#IntegrationTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#MatchingTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":15.0,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":59.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":294.75,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":983},"ACVARIANT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/acvariant/values/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ACVARIANT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Controlled Vocabulary for Audubon Core variant\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Audubon Core uses the terms ac:variant and ac:variantLiteral to provide information about the size, extent, and availability of the Service Access Point of a media item. This controlled vocabulary provides values for those terms.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Service access point\",\"Media item\"]","dct:title":"Audubon Core variant Controlled Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"TDWG Audubon Core Maintenance Group\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/657e8250-0eb9-013c-7f24-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/657e8250-0eb9-013c-7f24-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACVARIANT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"18"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2022-01-04T14:38:48.000-08:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-01-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://rs.tdwg.org/ac/doc/variant/\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"null","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACVARIANT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACVARIANT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"null","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"null","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACVARIANT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACVARIANT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACVARIANT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"3"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/acvariant/values/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/acvariant/values/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"null","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":90,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":90.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":68,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"null","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"null","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACVARIANT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"null","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"null","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":3.0,"normalizedScore":9,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"null","mod:prefLabelProperty":"null","mod:authorProperty":"null","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":1.0,"normalizedScore":3,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Steve Baskauf, Ed Baker]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACVARIANT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2020-10-13"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":224.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":738},"PHYTOTRAITS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/phytotraits/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/wghj-b028"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PHYTOTRAITS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Biodiversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Phytoplankton Traits Thesaurus\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Phytoplankton Traits Thesaurus is the first initiative to deal with the semantics of phytoplankton functional traits focusing on morpho-functional traits. It has been developed and published by LifeWatch Italy, the Italian node of the e-science European infrastructure for biodiversity and ecosystem research (LifeWatch ERIC). PhytoTraits reflects the agreement of a scientific expert community to fix semantic properties (e.g. label, definition) of approximately 120 traits. This resource has been deprecated. The concepts can be consulted in https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/traits/.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Phytoplankton Traits Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"LifeWatch Italy\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lifewatchitaly@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"94"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2023-09-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2015-03-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoinf.2017.10.014\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=PHYTOTRAITS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=PHYTOTRAITS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":75.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/phytotraits/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/wghj-b028"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/phytotraits/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"local:local\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"true","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":68,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/TRAITS_THES"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS/submissions/1","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Biodiversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/TRAITS_THES","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Elena Stanca, Ilaria Rosati]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3603-9316\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3603-9316\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alberto Basset\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a5b3c030-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/a5b3c030-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7205-3940\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7205-3940\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elena Stanca\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/84d4fbd0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/84d4fbd0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7346-6675\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7346-6675\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alessandra Pugnetti\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cd15f820-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cd15f820-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-9538-2966\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-9538-2966\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nicola Fiore\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bef355f0-0e49-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bef355f0-0e49-013c-7f22-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"nicola.fiore@equiup.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3422-7230\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3422-7230\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ilaria Rosati\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7534-3126\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7534-3126\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Angela Boggero\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd4b8d30-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd4b8d30-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0261-313X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0261-313X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paolo Tagliolato\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/95c13e40-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/95c13e40-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7997-219X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7997-219X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alessandro Oggioni\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/244a9c20-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/244a9c20-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0002-9415\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0002-9415\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Leonilde Roselli\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dbeed5e0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dbeed5e0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/syphax\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5946-6532\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5946-6532\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adriana Zingone\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bc9952a0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bc9952a0-0ec5-013c-c3a3-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Caterina Bergami\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9b083630-0ebf-013c-7f2c-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9b083630-0ebf-013c-7f2c-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PHYTOTRAITS/submissions/1","owl:versionInfo":"1.5"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":268.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":846},"PALEO_PROXY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy/2.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://linked.earth/ontology/#IntegrationTime","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PALEO_PROXY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy/2.0.0/index-en.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy#accumulation_rate","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Paleo Units Ontology defines different types of paleo units that we can find in a paleo climate dataset.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy/2.0.0/ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"The Paleo Proxy Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"pproxy","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"94"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[\"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy#PaleoProxy\",\"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy#PaleoProxyGeneral\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-12-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=PALEO_PROXY&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Cite as:\\r\\nhttp://earth.usc.edu/~khider/, http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5920-4751, http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/. The Paleo Proxy Ontology. Revision: 2.0.0. Retrieved from: http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy/2.0.0\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=PALEO_PROXY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/paleo_proxy#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.5,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":53.5,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Deborah Khider"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paleoclimate Dynamics Laboratory\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5920-4751\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5920-4751\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julien Emile-Geay\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://w3id.org/people/varunr\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e979b700-938b-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e979b700-938b-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":271.5,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":873},"ETS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://terminologies.gfbio.org/terms/ETS/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://terminologies.gfbio.org/terms/ets/2019-03-15/ets.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ETS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"http://terminologies.gfbio.org/terms/ETS/MeasurementOrFact\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Ecological Trait-data Standard defines terms for the use in datasets containing quantitative and qualitative functional traits.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.biodivportal.gfbio.org/ontologies/ETS/download?apikey=47a57aa3-7b54-4f34-b695-dbb5f5b7363e","omv:keywords":"[\"Standard\",\"Traits\"]","dct:title":"Ecological Trait-data Standard","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"GFBio Terminology Service\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8ad78230-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8ad78230-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/EcologicalTraitData/ETS"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"6","omv:numberOfProperties":"129","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ETS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2019-03-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210X.13288\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=ETS&q=","schema:comment":"[\"To contribute to this standard, see https://github.com/EcologicalTraitData/ETS\",\"For more information about this standard visit https://terminologies.gfbio.org/terms/ets/pages/\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ETS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ETS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2019-03-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ETS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=ETS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ETS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ETS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ETS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":72.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://terminologies.gfbio.org/terms/ETS/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://terminologies.gfbio.org/terms/ETS/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ETS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Florian Schneider"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nadja Simons\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/89df3640-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/89df3640-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andreas Ostrowski\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8a5734b0-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8a5734b0-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Malte Jochum\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8a289ff0-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8a289ff0-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gaëtane LeProvost\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/89fff130-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/89fff130-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Florian D. Schneider\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8a43f670-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8a43f670-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Caterina Penone\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8a13f3d0-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8a13f3d0-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"David Fichtmueller\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8a7561d0-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8a7561d0-9916-013d-e824-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ETS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.10"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":257.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":954},"FIP_ONTOLOGY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FIP-Ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"FIP_ONTOLOGY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/FAIR","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"https://w3id.org/fair/fip/latest/FIP-Question-A1.1-D","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This is an ontology of the FAIR Implementation Profiles (FIP) for the FAIR principles.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/peta-pico/FAIR-nanopubs/refs/heads/master/fip.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"FAIR Implementation Profile (FIP) Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"58","omv:numberOfProperties":"28","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"fip","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"35"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/\"]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/SIP-Declaration\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FIP-Declaration\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FAIR-Implementation-Profile\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FAIR-Declaration\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FAIR-Enabling-Resource\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/Available-FAIR-Enabling-Resource\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/Available-FAIR-Supporting-Resource\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FAIR-Practice\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/Semantic-Interoperability-Profile\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FIP-Question\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FAIR-Data-Policy\",\"https://peta-pico.github.io/FAIR-nanopubs/fip/index-en.html#https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FAIR-Case-Study\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-11-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-11-20T18:00:11.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=FIP_ONTOLOGY&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"4","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=FIP_ONTOLOGY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FIP-Ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/fair/fip/terms/FIP-Ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#, http://purl.org/pav/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"https://w3id.org/fair/principles/terms/\"]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.75,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Tobias Kuhn, Erik Schultes]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8888-635X\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9a318af0-2aae-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9a318af0-2aae-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2195-3997\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9a137b90-2aae-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9a137b90-2aae-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2195-3997\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2195-3997\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Barbara Magagna\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1f8f8be0-0d19-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/640add00-0d18-013c-7f08-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1267-0234\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/99dcdca0-2aae-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/99dcdca0-2aae-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-1267-0234\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-1267-0234\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tobias Kuhn\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0fca5120-8d46-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/0fca5120-8d46-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8888-635X\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8888-635X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Erik Schultes\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bef39a50-8d4d-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bef39a50-8d4d-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"OWL API\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":269.75,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1449},"MR":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://marineregions.org/ns/ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://marineregions.org/ontology/documentation.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MR","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://marineregions.org/ontology#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.marineregions.org/ontology/documentation.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Marine Regions ontology\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Marine Regions ontology provides definitions for the classes and properties used in the Marine Regions dataset.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://www.marineregions.org/ontology/ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Marine Regions ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0496vr396\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:0496vr396\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Flanders Marine Institute\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/41331060-0e47-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/41331060-0e47-013c-7f20-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/brittlnv\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"VLIZ\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Flanders Marine Institute\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6d35b670-efeb-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6d35b670-efeb-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.vliz.be/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marine Regions Data Management team\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/77c61710-0ebb-013c-7f26-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/77c61710-0ebb-013c-7f26-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"8","omv:numberOfProperties":"33","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"mr","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MR/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-19T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-03-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://www.vliz.be/en/imis?refid=346947\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=MR&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The Marine Regions Gazetteer ontology provides definitions for the classes and properties used in the [Marine Regions](//marineregions.org) gazetteer.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MR/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MR/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"4","dct:modified":"2021-12-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/MR/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=MR&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"6","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MR/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MR/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MR","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://marineregions.org/ns/ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://marineregions.org/ns/ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"local:false","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MR/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MR/submissions/4","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#comment","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#comment","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"local:false","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"local:false","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Marine Regions Data Management team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MR/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MR/submissions/4","owl:versionInfo":"1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":693},"ARCHIVE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/archive#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/archive/2.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://linked.earth/ontology/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ARCHIVE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://linked.earth/ontology/archive#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://linked.earth/ontology/archive/2.0.0/index-en.html#ArchiveType","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://linked.earth/ontology/archive#Borehole","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Archive Type Ontology defines different types of archive types that we can find in a paleo climate dataset.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Paleo climate dataset\",\"Archive types\"]","dct:title":"The Archive Type Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"archive","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"17"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[\"http://linked.earth/ontology/archive#ArchiveType\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-12-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=ARCHIVE&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Cite as:\\r\\nhttp://earth.usc.edu/~khider/, http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5920-4751, http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/. The Archive Type Ontology. Revision: 2.0.0. Retrieved from: http://linked.earth/ontology/archive/2.0.0\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ARCHIVE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=ARCHIVE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/archive#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/archive#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://linked.earth/ontology#"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.5,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://linked.earth/ontology#","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":53.5,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Julien Emile-Geay"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paleoclimate Dynamics Laboratory\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5920-4751\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5920-4751\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julien Emile-Geay\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0454-7145\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0454-7145\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniel Garijo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c585eb70-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c585eb70-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yolanda Gil\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c567da50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c567da50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":271.5,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":786},"MACROALGAETRAITS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/macroalgaetraits/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MACROALGAETRAITS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Biodiversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Macroalgae Traits Thesaurus contains several concepts on demographic and functional traits. It has been developed and published by LifeWatch Italy, the Italian node of the e-science European infrastructure for biodiversity and ecosystem research (LifeWatch ERIC). It reflects the agreement of a scientific expert community to fix semantic properties (e.g. label, definition) of approximately 100 traits. This resource has been deprecated. The concepts can be consulted in  https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/traits/.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Macroalgae Traits Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"LifeWatch Italy\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lifewatchitaly@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"109"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2023-09-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2018-10-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=MACROALGAETRAITS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=MACROALGAETRAITS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/TRAITS_THES","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/macroalgaetraits/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/macroalgaetraits/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"local:local\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"true","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":68,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS/submissions/1","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Biodiversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/TRAITS_THES","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Caterina Bergami, Simona Armeli Minicante, Ilaria Rosati]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simona Armeli Minicante\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/67c72090-3451-013c-2dad-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/67c72090-3451-013c-2dad-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"simona.armeli@ve.ismar.cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3422-7230\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3422-7230\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ilaria Rosati\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Caterina Bergami\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9b083630-0ebf-013c-7f2c-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9b083630-0ebf-013c-7f2c-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/MACROALGAETRAITS/submissions/1","owl:versionInfo":"1.5"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":244.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":388},"INTERPRETATION":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation/2.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://linked.earth/ontology/#IntegrationTime","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"INTERPRETATION","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation/2.0.0/index-en.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation/2.0.0/index-en.html#productivity","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Interpretation Ontology defines the different types of interpretation variables that we find in a paleo climate dataset.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation/2.0.0/ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"The Interpretation Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"interp","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"177"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[\"http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation#InterpretationSeasonality\",\"http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation#InterpretationVariable\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-12-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=INTERPRETATION&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Cite as:\\r\\nhttp://earth.usc.edu/~khider/, http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5920-4751, http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/. The Interpretation Ontology. Revision: 2.0.0. Retrieved from: http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation/2.0.0\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/INTERPRETATION/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=INTERPRETATION&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/interpretation#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.5,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":53.5,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Deborah Khider"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paleoclimate Dynamics Laboratory\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5920-4751\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5920-4751\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julien Emile-Geay\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://w3id.org/people/varunr\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e979b700-938b-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e979b700-938b-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":271.5,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":788},"SNOWTERM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabularyserver.com/cnr/ml/snowterm/en/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.isp.cnr.it/index.php/en/snowterm","void:uriRegexPattern":"https://vocabularyserver.com/cnr/ml/snowterm/en/","omv:acronym":"SNOWTERM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://vocabularyserver.com/cnr/ml/snowterm/en/","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20923\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/10\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20918\"]","dct:coverage":"Polar and mountain environments","dct:audience":"National Research Council of Italy (CNR), Institute of Polar Sciences","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"https://vocabularyserver.com/cnr/ml/snowterm/en/xml.php?skosTema=48850","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SnowTerm is an example of a structured reference multilingual scientific and technical vocabulary, covering the terminology of a specific knowledge domain in the polar and the mountain environment. The thematic areas, covered at present, deal with snow and ice physics, snow and ice morphology, snow and ice radiometry, remote sensing and GIS applied to cryosphere environment, sea ice, avalanches, glaciers.,","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/26L-TSCPDT8M-8\",\"http://data.loterre.fr/vocabs/BGI/GT/763\",\"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/26L-S456Q9Z7-G\",\"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/26L-L2QGBDWF-M\"]","dct:title":"SnowTerm Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"CNR-ISP-EKOLab\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bd2eef40-8955-013d-4715-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bd2eef40-8955-013d-4715-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"4958"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://vocabularyserver.com/cnr/ml/snowterm/en/xml.php?skosTema=20170\",\"https://vocabularyserver.com/cnr/ml/snowterm/en/xml.php?skosTema=1010\",\"https://vocabularyserver.com/cnr/ml/snowterm/en/xml.php?skosTema=1050\",\"https://vocabularyserver.com/cnr/ml/snowterm/en/xml.php?skosTema=10\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-11-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"SnowTerm is the result of ongoing work on a structured reference multilingual scientific and technical vocabulary covering the terminology of a specific knowledge domain like the polar and the mountain environment. The terminological system contains around 3.700 terms and it is arranged according to the EARTh thesaurus semantic model. It is foreseen as an updated and expanded version of this system.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2014-11-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://www.nomos-elibrary.de/10.5771/9783956508752-115.pdf\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=SNOWTERM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2024-02-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/SNOWTERM/download","foaf:logo":"https://www.isp.cnr.it/images/thesauri/Snow_EN-link.png","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=SNOWTERM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabularyserver.com/cnr/ml/snowterm/en/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabularyserver.com/cnr/ml/snowterm/en/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20923\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/10\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20918\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.75,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Paolo Plini, Sabina Di Franco]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-6862-2170\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-6862-2170\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sabina Di Franco\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7e71fd90-895d-013d-4fa9-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7e71fd90-895d-013d-4fa9-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"sabina.difranco@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"CNR-ISP-EKOLab\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bd2eef40-8955-013d-4715-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/bd2eef40-8955-013d-4715-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-7315-3364\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-7315-3364\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paolo Plini\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/67b14da0-895d-013d-4fa9-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/67b14da0-895d-013d-4fa9-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"paolo.plini@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-6862-2170\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-6862-2170\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sabina Di Franco\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7e71fd90-895d-013d-4fa9-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7e71fd90-895d-013d-4fa9-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"sabina.difranco@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-7315-3364\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-7315-3364\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paolo Plini\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/67b14da0-895d-013d-4fa9-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/67b14da0-895d-013d-4fa9-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"paolo.plini@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"Glossario dei termini usati nei bollettini nivometeorologici by AINEVA and by Friuli-Venezia Giulia Region\",\"Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) \\\"Special Report On The Ocean And Cryosphere In A Changing Climate - Glossary\\\"\",\"M. Maisch & P. Wick: dns-Themenheft \\u201eGletscher\\u201c, Nr. 7/8 (2004) and J. G. Cogley et al.: Glossary of glacier mass balance and related terms, IHP-VII Technical Documents in Hydrology No. 86, IACS Contribution No. 2, UNESCO-IHP, Paris (2011)\",\"\\\"Vecjezicni Slovar - Sneg in plazovi\\\" developed by Pavle ?egula\",\"American Geophysical Union (AGU) Glossary of Ice Terminology\",\"National Snow and Ice Data Center (NSIDC) Cryosphere glossary\",\"\\\"Sea Ice Nomenclature\\\" (Merenkulkulaitoksen julkaisuja 5/2002)\",\"USGS Glossary of Selected Glacier and Related Terminology\",\"Trilingual \\\"Glossary on snow and avalanches\\\" by the Working Group on Avalanches Warning Services of the Swiss Federal Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research\",\"Sea Ice Glossary of the Scientific Committee on Antarctic Research-SCAR\",\"Barry, R., & Gan, T. (2011). Glossary. In The Global Cryosphere: Past, Present and Future (pp. 350-357). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. doi:10.1017/CBO9780511977947.014\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":55.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":275.75,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5112},"PPI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PPI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Plant_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Animal_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Biodiversity_Conservation\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Plant-Pollinator Interactions (PPI) is a vocabulary of terms for transmitting information about plant-pollinator interactions using the Darwin Core standard. This document lists all terms in namespaces currently used in the vocabulary., Term list for plant-pollinator interactions vocabulary","omv:resourceLocator":"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Plant-Pollinator Interactions","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/f.mirandasoares\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"REBIPP\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Brazilian Network on Plant-Pollinator Interactions (REBIPP)\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ab973040-f21a-013d-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ab973040-f21a-013d-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ppi","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PPI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerOpeningPeriod\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/accumulatedNectarConcentration\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/selfIncompatibilityType\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/apomiticSystemEmbryoOrigin\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/antherPollenGrainsQuantity\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerOpeningType\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/coloredFlowerStructure\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/seedSet\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/styleLengthInMilimiters\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/stigmaticAreaInSquareMilimiters\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/accumlatedNectarVolumeInMicroliters\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/accumulatedNectarFlowers\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/Interaction\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/NectarDynamics\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/seedMassInMiligrams\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/visitedFlowerSex\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfFertilizedOvules\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/matingSystem\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerColor\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/Flower\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/apomiticSystemFertilization\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfHeterospecificPollenGrains\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfPollenTubes\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/floralAttractants\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/ReproductiveSuccess\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerAbundance\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/nectarCollectingBodyPartLengthInMilimiters\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfExposedFlowers\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfConspecificPollenGrains\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/plantHabit\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerOrientation\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/ovuleQuantity\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/fruitSet\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/functionalFlowerLifespanInHours\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/resourceCollected\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/apomiticSystemReproduction\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/humanUse\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/sexualSystem\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/animalPlaceOfContact\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfRemovedPollenGrains\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/floralSystem\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerLongevity\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/caste\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/antherDehiscenceType\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/Animal\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/accumulatedNectarHours\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/nectarCollectingBodyPart\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/Plant\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerShape\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/fruitMassInGrams\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/floralSymmetry\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/visitedFlowersQuantity\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerPlaceOfContact\"]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-04-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-12-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PPI&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Term list for plant-pollinator interactions vocabulary\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PPI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PPI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PPI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PPI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PPI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PPI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PPI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerOpeningPeriod\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/accumulatedNectarConcentration\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/selfIncompatibilityType\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/apomiticSystemEmbryoOrigin\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/antherPollenGrainsQuantity\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerOpeningType\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/coloredFlowerStructure\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/seedSet\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/styleLengthInMilimiters\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/stigmaticAreaInSquareMilimiters\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/accumlatedNectarVolumeInMicroliters\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/accumulatedNectarFlowers\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/Interaction\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/NectarDynamics\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/seedMassInMiligrams\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/visitedFlowerSex\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfFertilizedOvules\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/matingSystem\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerColor\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/Flower\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/apomiticSystemFertilization\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfHeterospecificPollenGrains\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfPollenTubes\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/floralAttractants\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/ReproductiveSuccess\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerAbundance\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/nectarCollectingBodyPartLengthInMilimiters\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfExposedFlowers\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfConspecificPollenGrains\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/plantHabit\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerOrientation\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/ovuleQuantity\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/fruitSet\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/functionalFlowerLifespanInHours\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/resourceCollected\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/apomiticSystemReproduction\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/humanUse\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/sexualSystem\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/animalPlaceOfContact\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/numberOfRemovedPollenGrains\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/floralSystem\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerLongevity\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/caste\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/antherDehiscenceType\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/Animal\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/accumulatedNectarHours\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/nectarCollectingBodyPart\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/Plant\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerShape\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/fruitMassInGrams\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/floralSymmetry\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/visitedFlowersQuantity\",\"http://rs.rebipp.org.br/ppi/terms/flowerPlaceOfContact\"]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PPI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Plant_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Animal_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Biodiversity_Conservation\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"José Augusto Salim"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PPI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":225.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3373},"ECOTOXICTHES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/3WV"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.inist.fr","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ECOTOXICTHES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Applied_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This bilingual, French-English thesaurus structures the key concepts of ecotoxicology, the study of the impact of pollutants on ecosystems, with searchable synonyms. The resource area includes risks to human health. It also contains terms from geography, animal and plant taxonomy and chemical compounds. It uses polyhierarchy. Concepts are grouped into semantic categories. Definitions are given for some concepts., Ce thésaurus bilingue, français-anglais, structure les concepts-clefs de l?écotoxicologie, étude de l?impact des polluants sur les écosystèmes, accompagnés de synonymes interrogeables. Le domaine de la ressource englobe les risques pour la santé humaine. Il contient également des termes de géographie, de taxonomie animale et végétale et de composés chimiques. Il utilise la polyhiérarchie. Les concepts sont regroupés par catégories sémantiques. Des définitions sont données pour certains concepts.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ecotoxicology thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"4","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOTOXICTHES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"4816"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-07-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2017-11-21T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ECOTOXICTHES&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This resource contains 4741 terminological entries grouped into 73 collections.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOTOXICTHES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOTOXICTHES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2022-07-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOTOXICTHES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ECOTOXICTHES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/fra]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOTOXICTHES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOTOXICTHES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOTOXICTHES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"4"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://loterre.fr, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://loterre.fr, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/3WV","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/3WV"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOTOXICTHES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Applied_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Contact"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"INIST\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"02mn0vt57\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:02mn0vt57\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institut de l'Information Scientifique et Technique\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b68a7ec0-0dfb-013c-7f10-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b68a7ec0-0dfb-013c-7f10-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOTOXICTHES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":941},"ACTRIS_CL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_controlled_lists/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"Support ACTRIS Vocabulary\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/skosmos/actris_ctrl_lists/en/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ACTRIS_CL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_controlled_lists/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"ACTRIS stakeholders","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/ACTRIS-Data-Centre/actris-vocabulary/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"https://dc.actris.nilu.no\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"ACTRIS Controlled Lists\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Lists of controlled terms used in ACTRIS","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ACTRIS-Data-Centre/actris-vocabulary/refs/heads/main/ACTRIS_controlled_lists.ttl","omv:keywords":"[\"ACTRIS terms\",\"ACTRIS roles\",\"ACTRIS framework\",\"ACTRIS glossary\"]","dct:title":"ACTRIS Controlled Lists","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"ACTRIS\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Aerosol, Clouds and Trace Gases Research Infrastructure (ACTRIS)\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9f6feee0-a960-013c-1b52-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9f6feee0-a960-013c-1b52-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.actris.eu\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ACTRIS_ctrl_lists","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"191"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2022-12-16T16:40:00.000+01:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ACTRIS_CL&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ACTRIS_CL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_controlled_lists/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_controlled_lists/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_vocab/, http://publications.europa.eu/ontology/euvoc#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/pav/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_vocab/, http://publications.europa.eu/ontology/euvoc#]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Markus Fiebig"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3380-3470/\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/98e1b670-ebfd-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/98e1b670-ebfd-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3380-3470\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3380-3470\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Fiebig\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/af44f450-9741-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/af44f450-9741-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"mf@nilu.no\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9250-9813/\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/99114e10-ebfd-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/99114e10-ebfd-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9250-9813\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9250-9813\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Richard Olav Rud\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/43356a10-ac87-013c-1b52-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/43356a10-ac87-013c-1b52-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"ror@nilu.no\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3380-3470\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3380-3470\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Fiebig\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/af44f450-9741-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/af44f450-9741-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"mf@nilu.no\",\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#SearchTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"ACTRIS\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Aerosol, Clouds and Trace Gases Research Infrastructure (ACTRIS)\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9f6feee0-a960-013c-1b52-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9f6feee0-a960-013c-1b52-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.actris.eu\"}]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":15.0,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":271.75,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1037},"ECOCORE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ecocore.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ecocore/releases/2022-03-09/ecocore.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/EcologicalSemantics/ecocore","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ECOCORE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Environmental_Sciences\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Species_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/EcologicalSemantics/an-ontology-of-core-ecological-entities/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"ecology-core-ontology@googlegroups.com","dct:description":"This ontology aims to provide core semantics for ecological entities, such as ecological functions (for predators, prey, etc), food webs, and ecological interactions. The ontology, closely interoperates with existing OBO ontologies such as the Environment Ontology, the Population and Community Ontology (PCO), the Relations Ontology (RO), the Gene Ontology (for biological processes etc), the Phenotype and Quality Ontology (PATO), the Plant Ontology (PO), and many others. Ecocore is under active development.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/EcologicalSemantics/ecocore/refs/heads/master/ecocore.owl","omv:keywords":"[\"Ecological functions\",\"Environment\"]","dct:title":"An ontology of core ecological entities","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/EcologicalSemantics/ecocore"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"5586","omv:numberOfProperties":"295","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOCORE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"17"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"37","dct:created":"2018-07-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ECOCORE&q=","schema:comment":"[\"An ontology of core ecological entities\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOCORE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOCORE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1211","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOCORE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ECOCORE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"406","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOCORE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOCORE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOCORE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1149"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://aber-owl.net, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://aber-owl.net, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":14.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":91.0,"normalizedScore":80,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ecocore.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ecocore.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pato#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chebi/, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uberon/core#, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BCO]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pato#, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chebi/, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uberon/core#, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BCO]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOCORE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Environmental_Sciences\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Species_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/ECO\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":53.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"18"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Pier Luigi Buttigieg"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECOCORE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2022-03-09"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":288.75,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1308},"N2000_HABITATS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/n2000habitats/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/n2000habitats/view","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"N2000_HABITATS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/n2000habitats/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/n2000habitats/6170","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Annex I habitats for Natura 2000.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Annex I habitats for Natura 2000","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"02k4b9v70\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:02k4b9v70\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"European Environment Agency\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/44daac70-b4ba-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/44daac70-b4ba-013d-f09b-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"n2000habitats","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"533"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-01-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Natura 2000 is an ecological network of protected areas, set up to ensure the survival of Europe's most valuable species and habitats. Natura 2000 is based on the 1979 Birds Directive and the 1992 Habitats Directive. Natura 2000 is the key instrument to protect biodiversity in the European Union.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2013-08-07T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/search?ontologies=N2000_HABITATS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/search?ontologies=N2000_HABITATS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://dd.eionet.europa.eu]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://dd.eionet.europa.eu]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/n2000habitats/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/n2000habitats/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#classification_schema)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#classification_schema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#classification_schema","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"European Environment Agency"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":262.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":901},"ISO_639-2":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/common/iso639-2/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.loc.gov/standards/iso639-2/langhome.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ISO_639-2","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/OTHER\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"ISO 639-2 is part of the ISO 639 language code family, which provides also a two-character code set (ISO 639-1) for the representation of names of languages. ISO 639-2 contains codes for all languages contained in ISO 639-1 and several hundred additional languages. The ISO 639-2 (Bibliographic) codes were devised for use in bibliographic metadata, e.g., for libraries, information services, and publishers, and ISO 639-2 (Terminology) targets terminology, lexicography, and linguistic applications. The lists are the same except for 20 languages that have different Bibliographic and Terminology codes. The list contains over 500 discrete codes.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.2/oboe-core.owl#Standard\",\"http://www.eionet.europa.eu/gemet/concept/11431\",\"http://ncicb.nci.nih.gov/xml/owl/EVS/Thesaurus.owl#C51279\"]","dct:title":"ISO 639-2: Codes for the Representation of Names of Languages - Part 2: Alpha-3 Code for the Names of Languages","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ISO_639-2/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"487"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-11-19T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2019-07-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=ISO_639-2&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ISO_639-2/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ISO_639-2/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2024-11-15T15:16:15.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ISO_639-2/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=ISO_639-2&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ISO_639-2/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ISO_639-2/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ISO_639-2","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/common/iso639-2/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/common/iso639-2/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#list)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#list"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ISO_639-2/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/OTHER\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#list","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Contact"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ISO_639-2/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":765},"GEOLOGIC_UNITS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?lang=en","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"GEOLOGIC_UNITS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/941","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The theme Geological Units comprises various units and symbols which were formalised as points, linear or polygonal features on geological maps and covers lithostratigraphic units of the Austrian Stratigraphic Chart (Piller et al., 2004), lithogenetic, lithodemic units and geomorphologic units. Informal subdivisions of the \"Stratigraphic Chart of Austria\" - most of them are geographic names - are indicated by square brackets and must not be used for coding.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"https://service.poleterresolide.fr/voc/science_field/D040000\",\"https://service.poleterresolide.fr/voc/science_field/D060000\"]","dct:title":"Geologic Units","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"GeologicUnit","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"960"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/332&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/969&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/295&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/358&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/252&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/123&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/197&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/207&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/338&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/968&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/115&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/122&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/342&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/206&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/198&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/275&lang=en\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-11-21T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2019-07-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/bibl_res.html?proj=GeologicUnit\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=GEOLOGIC_UNITS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=GEOLOGIC_UNITS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"3"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/GeologicUnit/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://resource.geolba.ac.at/PoolParty/sparql/GeologicUnit\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/at/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.75,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/at/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Geological Survey of Austria"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Schiegl M.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7be3ab80-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7be3ab80-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Huet B.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/484c5bb0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/484c5bb0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Reiser M.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/79df5560-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/79df5560-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dobramysl L.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/137df220-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/137df220-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Linner M.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/60648870-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/60648870-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Iglseder Ch.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4f010d80-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/4f010d80-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Reitner J.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/88bbf8f0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/88bbf8f0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Haider V.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3aa4b7b0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/3aa4b7b0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ebner M.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/33610d90-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/33610d90-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Schuster R.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/948fdeb0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/948fdeb0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Krenmayr H.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/55743700-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/55743700-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Palzer-Khomenko M.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6bb2c410-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/6bb2c410-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Auer Ch.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f52363d0-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f52363d0-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lipiarski P.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/660fea80-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/660fea80-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pavlik B.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/727bdce0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/727bdce0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Weber L.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9a4eac10-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9a4eac10-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Schedl A.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8eb5f5c0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8eb5f5c0-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hintersberger E.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/420b6050-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/420b6050-8af4-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hörfarter Ch.\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cb3e5060-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/cb3e5060-8af3-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":55.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":265.75,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":623},"PORO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/releases/2016-10-06/poro.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/obophenotype/porifera-ontology","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PORO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Species_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Porifera (sponge) ontology\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":" An ontology describing the anatomical structures and characteristics of Porifera (sponges).","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/obophenotype/porifera-ontology/refs/heads/master/poro.owl","omv:keywords":"[\"phenotype\",\"trait\"]","dct:title":"Porifera Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"896","omv:numberOfProperties":"54","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-05-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"6","dct:created":"2014-07-19T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PORO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"153","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PORO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"162","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"39"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":12.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":89.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/cl_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/chebi_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/go_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/ro_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/pato_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/uberon_import.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/cl_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/chebi_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/go_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/ro_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/pato_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/uberon_import.owl]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Species_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"12"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Bob Thacker"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bob Thacker\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/32e55c90-1ec2-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/32e55c90-1ec2-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Chris Mungall\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/32feec00-1ec2-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/32feec00-1ec2-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":284.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1233},"LIPD_ONTOLOGY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology/core/2.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://linked.earth/ontology/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LIPD_ONTOLOGY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://linked.earth/ontology#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://linked.earth/ontology/core/2.0.0/index-en.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"https://linked.earth/ontology/core/2.0.0/index-en.html#hasNoaaPastName","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The LiPD Ontology aims to provide a common vocabulary for annotating paleoclimatology data., The LiPD Ontology aims to provide a common vocabulary for annotating paleoclimatology data","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"The Linked Earth Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"39","omv:numberOfProperties":"133","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"le","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"5"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ARCHIVE\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/INSTRUMENT\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/INTERPRETATION\"]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#CoreOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://linked.earth/ontology/core/2.0.0/index-en.html#Interpretation\",\"https://linked.earth/ontology/core/2.0.0/index-en.html#PaleoData\",\"https://linked.earth/ontology/core/2.0.0/index-en.html#ChronData\",\"https://linked.earth/ontology/core/2.0.0/index-en.html#PaleoModel\",\"https://linked.earth/ontology/core/2.0.0/index-en.html#ChronModel\",\"https://linked.earth/ontology/core/2.0.0/index-en.html#Instrument\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-12-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-12-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=LIPD_ONTOLOGY&q=","schema:comment":"[\"\\r\\nCite as:\\r\\nhttp://earth.usc.edu/~khider/, http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5920-4751, http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/. The Linked Earth Core Ontology. Revision: 2.0.0. Retrieved from: http://linked.earth/ontology/core/2.0.0\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"6","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=LIPD_ONTOLOGY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"10","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"24"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://linked.earth/ontology#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.linkedmodel.org/schema/vaem#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.5,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ARCHIVE\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/INSTRUMENT\",\"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/INTERPRETATION\"]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.5,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Julien Emile-Geay"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paleoclimate Dynamics Laboratory\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c516f840-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.cefns.nau.edu/~npm4/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"USCDornsife, Department of Earth Sciences\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c4e375d0-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://earth.usc.edu/~khider/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5920-4751\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5920-4751\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julien Emile-Geay\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c5316b50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0454-7145\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0454-7145\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniel Garijo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c585eb70-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c585eb70-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yolanda Gil\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c567da50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/c567da50-92e0-013d-0f4c-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":264.5,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":820},"EUROVOC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://eurovoc.europa.eu/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://op.europa.eu/s/y4TH","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EUROVOC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/OTHER\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://op.europa.eu/o/opportal-service/euvoc-download-handler?cellarURI=http%3A%2F%2Fpublications.europa.eu%2Fresource%2Fdistribution%2Fdocumentation%2Feurovoc%2Fhandbook%2Fpdf%2Fstddoc%2FEuroVoc-Handbook.pdf&fileName=EuroVoc-Handbook.pdf","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"EuroVoc\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"EuroVoc is a multilingual, multidisciplinary thesaurus covering the activities of the EU. It contains terms in 24 EU languages, plus in three languages of countries which are candidate for EU accession.  \r\nEuroVoc is managed by the Publications Office of the European Union, which moved forward to ontology-based thesaurus management and semantic web technologies conformant to W3C recommendations as well as latest trends in thesaurus standards. \r\nEuroVoc users include the European Union institutions, the Publications Office of the EU, national and regional parliaments in Europe, plus national governments and private users around the world.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Communication\"]","dct:title":"EuroVoc","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"5","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROVOC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"472139"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-05-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-12-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=EUROVOC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROVOC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROVOC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROVOC/download","foaf:logo":"https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/0/03/EuroVoc_logo.jpeg","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=EUROVOC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"5","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROVOC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROVOC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROVOC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"5"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://op.europa.eu/it/web/eu-vocabularies/controlled-vocabularies, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://op.europa.eu/it/web/eu-vocabularies/controlled-vocabularies, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://eurovoc.europa.eu/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://eurovoc.europa.eu/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":68,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROVOC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/OTHER\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":" Publications Office of the European Union"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"016jmhr98\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:016jmhr98\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\" Publications Office of the European Union\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b9686820-0eba-013c-7f25-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b9686820-0eba-013c-7f25-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUROVOC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"4.21"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":921},"ALIENSPECIES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/alienspecies/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/xb7h-dw52"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ALIENSPECIES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/msa0031\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20728\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Alien Species Thesaurus\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Alien Species Thesaurus is an initiative to deal with the semantics about alien and invasive species. It has been developed and published by LifeWatch Italy, the Italian node of the e-science European infrastructure for biodiversity and ecosystem research (LifeWatch ERIC).\r\n It is developed on the basis of already existing glossaries created within the framework of international initiatives aimed at the study of alien and invasive species. The terms (or concepts) are shared very broadly by the scientific community, and their definitions derive from guidelines prepared by relevant international organizations, and only in few occasions by peer reviewed papers. The Thesaurus currently consists of 157 terms.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Management measures\"]","dct:title":"Alien Species Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"LifeWatch Italy\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lifewatchitaly@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"165"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2023-09-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-05-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://www.lifewatchitaly.eu/publications/#1590425563910-01d9d51a-b764\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=ALIENSPECIES&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=ALIENSPECIES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":77.0,"normalizedScore":68,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/alienspecies/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/xb7h-dw52"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/alienspecies/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"local:local\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES/submissions/1","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/msa0031\",\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/20728\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Ilaria Rosati, Angela Boggero]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0283-3618\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0283-3618\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paolo Colangelo\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fcded0d0-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fcded0d0-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-6125-3322\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-6125-3322\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cataldo  Pierri\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fcb74170-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fcb74170-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3170-0774\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3170-0774\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fabio  Cianferoni\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd06db10-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd06db10-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"fabio.cianferoni@unifi.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3422-7230\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3422-7230\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ilaria Rosati\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7534-3126\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7534-3126\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Angela Boggero\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd4b8d30-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/fd4b8d30-0ebb-013c-7f27-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES/submissions/1","owl:versionInfo":"2.5"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":52.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":275.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":639},"ACSUBTYPE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/acsubtype/values/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://rs.tdwg.org/ac/doc/subtype/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ACSUBTYPE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Controlled Vocabulary for Audubon Core subtype\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Audubon Core uses the terms ac:subtype and ac:subtypeLiteral to refine the type of a media item to a level more specific than the Dublin Core Type Vocabulary, http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/. This controlled vocabulary provides values for ac:subtype and ac:subtypeLiteral.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Media types\"]","dct:title":"Audubon Core subtype Controlled Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"TDWG Audubon Core Maintenance Group\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/657e8250-0eb9-013c-7f24-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/657e8250-0eb9-013c-7f24-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"TDWG\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Biodiversity Information Standards\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/35835710-b9cf-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/35835710-b9cf-013c-690d-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"secretary@tdwg.org\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"23","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACSUBTYPE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2022-01-04T14:32:32.000-08:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-01-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://rs.tdwg.org/ac/doc/subtype/\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"null","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACSUBTYPE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACSUBTYPE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"null","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"null","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACSUBTYPE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACSUBTYPE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACSUBTYPE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"23"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/acsubtype/values/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rs.tdwg.org/acsubtype/values/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"null","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":90,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":90.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACSUBTYPE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#terminology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#comment","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#comment","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"null","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Steve Baskauf, Ed Baker]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACSUBTYPE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2020-10-13"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":237.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":714},"AGRIPROD":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://publications.europa.eu/resource/dataset/agriprod"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AGRIPROD","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Agricultural products (AGRIPROD) is a list of the agricultural products.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Agricultural products","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"4","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGRIPROD/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"4632"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-07-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-06-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=AGRIPROD&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGRIPROD/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGRIPROD/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGRIPROD/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=AGRIPROD&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGRIPROD/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGRIPROD/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGRIPROD","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"4"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":58.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://publications.europa.eu/resource/dataset/agriprod","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://publications.europa.eu/resource/dataset/agriprod"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGRIPROD/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Cristina Di Muri"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/AGRIPROD/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":202.0,"normalizedScore":42,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":653},"GEO_STRUCTURES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?lang=en","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"GEO_STRUCTURES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/121","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Theme Geologic Structures includes linear and planar predominantly deformation structures in geologic maps. Shear sense indicators and fold structures are also covered by this theme.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/26L-GVBC0S78-7\",\"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/26L-SR7F4VQX-7\",\"http://data.loterre.fr/vocabs/BGI/GT/3017\",\"http://data.loterre.fr/ark:/67375/26L-SGP202VS-Z\"]","dct:title":"Geologic Structures","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"structure","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"285"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/60&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/52&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/2&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/10&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/397&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/62&lang=en\",\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/index.html?uri=http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/61&lang=en\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-11-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2019-07-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://thesaurus.geolba.ac.at/bibl_res.html?proj=structure\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=GEO_STRUCTURES&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2019-07-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=GEO_STRUCTURES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://resource.geolba.ac.at/structure/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"https://resource.geolba.ac.at/PoolParty/sparql/structure\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/at/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/at/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Geological Survey of Austria"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":255.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":498},"PCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pco/pco-full.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pco/releases/2021-05-03/pco-full.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/PopulationAndCommunityOntology/pco","void:uriRegexPattern":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/PCO_[0-9]{7}","omv:acronym":"PCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/PCO_","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/PopulationAndCommunityOntology/pco","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/PopulationAndCommunityOntology/pco/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/PCO_0000061","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Population and Community Ontology\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Population and Community Ontology (PCO) describes material entities, qualities, and processes related to collections of interacting organisms such as populations and communities. It is taxon neutral, and can be used for any species, including humans. The classes in the PCO are useful for describing evolutionary processes, organismal interactions, and ecological experiments. Practical applications of the PCO include community health care, plant pathology, behavioral studies, sociology, and ecology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.biodivportal.gfbio.org/ontologies/PCO/download?apikey=8d904e8e-41f9-454d-bbca-5184a9da4109","omv:keywords":"[\"data management\",\"model organisms\"]","dct:title":"Population and Community Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/PopulationAndCommunityOntology/pco"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"221","omv:numberOfProperties":"110","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"pco","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"18"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-02-13T18:00:59.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0089606\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=PCO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The Population and Community Ontology (PCO) is licensed under a Creative Commons zero (CC0) license - http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/. You can copy, modify, distribute and perform the work, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. We ask that anyone using this ontology follow the standards of the scientific ontology community by re-using ontology identifiers whenever possible and properly citing the ontology and its creators.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"70","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/PCO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=PCO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"73","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://obofoundry.org, https://aber-owl.net, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://vest.agrisemantics.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols, https://biosharing.org/bsg-s002830]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://obofoundry.org, https://aber-owl.net, https://biodivportal.gfbio.org, https://agroportal.lirmm.fr, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://vest.agrisemantics.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols, https://biosharing.org/bsg-s002830]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":94.0,"normalizedScore":83,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pco/pco-full.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pco/pco-full.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pato.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/go.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#hasExactSynonym","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label","dct:relation":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/pato.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/go.owl]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO/submissions/1","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/IAO_0000115","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/IAO_0000115","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#label","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#hasExactSynonym"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"30"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"You can copy, modify, distribute and perform the work, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. We ask that anyone using this ontology follow the standards of the scientific ontology community by re-using ontology identifiers whenever possible and properly citing the ontology and its creators."},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Ramona Walls"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":29.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8815-0078\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8815-0078\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ramona Walls\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-7073-9172\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-7073-9172\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"David Osumi-Sutherland\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9aad5170-cc2a-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9aad5170-cc2a-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-4366-3088\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-4366-3088\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pier Luigi Buttigieg\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/895ddf30-cc2a-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/895ddf30-cc2a-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jie Zheng\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ac52a9e0-cc2a-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/ac52a9e0-cc2a-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8815-0078\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8815-0078\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ramona Walls\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/59017e90-0e43-013c-7f1a-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-4366-3088\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-4366-3088\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pier Luigi Buttigieg\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/895ddf30-cc2a-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/895ddf30-cc2a-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO/submissions/1","owl:versionInfo":"2021-05-03"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"OWL API\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"RDA Wheat Data Interoperability Guidelines\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e4a77030-cc2a-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/e4a77030-cc2a-013d-2bf2-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":309.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1586},"ZOOPLANKTRAITS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/zooplanktontraits/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":11.0,"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/96f7-fb90"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ZOOPLANKTRAITS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Biodiversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Zooplankton Traits Thesaurus\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Zooplankton Traits Thesaurus contains several concepts mainly on zooplankton morpho-functional traits. It has been developed and published by LifeWatch Italy, the Italian node of the e-science European infrastructure for biodiversity and ecosystem research (LifeWatch ERIC). It reflects the agreement of a scientific expert community to fix semantic properties (e.g. label, definition) of approximately 90 traits. This resource has been deprecated. The concepts can be consulted in https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/traits/.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Zooplankton Traits Thesaurus","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"LifeWatch Italy\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f1e32a30-2eb5-013c-ded4-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lifewatchitaly@gmail.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"57"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2023-09-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2019-05-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoinf.2017.10.014\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=ZOOPLANKTRAITS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://193.204.79.66:8080/search?ontologies=ZOOPLANKTRAITS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":75.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/zooplanktontraits/","dct:identifier":"https://doi.org/10.48373/96f7-fb90"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/zooplanktontraits/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"local:local\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"true","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/TRAITS_THES"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS/submissions/1","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Biodiversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/TRAITS_THES","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":43,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Caterina Bergami, Ilaria Rosati]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3422-7230\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3422-7230\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ilaria Rosati\",\"affiliations\":[{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27cda670-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/27dca2e0-0e42-013c-7f19-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Caterina Bergami\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9b083630-0ebf-013c-7f2c-000c29bb32fb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9b083630-0ebf-013c-7f2c-000c29bb32fb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/ZOOPLANKTRAITS/submissions/1","owl:versionInfo":"1.5"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":273.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":453},"ACTRIS_VOCAB":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_vocab/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"ACTRIS measurement data and data products relevant to climate and air quality research for all interested users\"]","foaf:homepage":"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/skosmos/actris_vocab/en/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ACTRIS_VOCAB","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_vocab/","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21920\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"ACTRIS stakeholders","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/ACTRIS-Data-Centre/actris-vocabulary/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"https://dc.actris.nilu.no/\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"ACTRIS Vocabulary\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Controlled vocabulary of terms used in ACTRIS","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ACTRIS-Data-Centre/actris-vocabulary/refs/heads/main/ACTRIS_vocabulary.ttl","omv:keywords":"[\"Cloud variables\",\"Aerosol\",\"Trace gas variables\"]","dct:title":"ACTRIS Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ACTRIS_vocab","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"5614"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2022-12-16T17:00:00.000+01:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/skosmos/actris_vocab/en/\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ACTRIS_VOCAB&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB/download?download_format=rdf","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=ACTRIS_VOCAB&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_vocab/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://vocabulary.actris.nilu.no/actris_vocab/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/, http://publications.europa.eu/ontology/euvoc#, http://vocab.nerc.ac.uk/collection/, https://commonchemistry.cas.org/detail?cas_rn=]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/pav/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/, http://publications.europa.eu/ontology/euvoc#, http://vocab.nerc.ac.uk/collection/, https://commonchemistry.cas.org/detail?cas_rn=]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/EnvThes/21920\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Markus Fiebig"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3380-3470\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/728f8520-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/728f8520-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3380-3470\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3380-3470\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Fiebig\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/af44f450-9741-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/af44f450-9741-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"mf@nilu.no\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5158-8703\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/736f01e0-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/736f01e0-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2972-2851\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2972-2851\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cathy Boonne\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/34a32010-9744-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/34a32010-9744-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"cathy.boonne@ipsl.jussieu.fr\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8301-1319\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/73439640-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/73439640-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2972-2851\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7358a2c0-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7358a2c0-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5158-8703\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5158-8703\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bénédicte Picquet-Varrault\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8c33d940-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/8c33d940-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"benedicte.picquet-varrault@lisa.ipsl.fr\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8981-0805\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/732f7c50-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/732f7c50-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4157-0838\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7385b6e0-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/7385b6e0-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-8981-0805\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-8981-0805\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tove Svendby\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dd8a6a10-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/dd8a6a10-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"tms@nilu.no\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-8712-4262\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-8712-4262\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yong Lin\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1e59ac50-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1e59ac50-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"yl@nilu.no\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9834-5100\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/72e77430-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/72e77430-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9834-5100\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9834-5100\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"E. J. O'Connor\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f0b7a7e0-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/f0b7a7e0-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"e.oconnor@reading.ac.uk\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-4157-0838\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-4157-0838\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lucia Mona\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b998ff40-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/b998ff40-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"lucia.mona@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8301-1319\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8301-1319\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Claudio Dema\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2900c480-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/2900c480-9742-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"claudio.dema@cnr.it\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8712-4262\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/739e5b80-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/739e5b80-eb34-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3380-3470\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3380-3470\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Fiebig\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/af44f450-9741-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/af44f450-9741-013c-07ef-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"mf@nilu.no\",\"homepage\":null}]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#IntegrationTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#MatchingTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#FilteringTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#IndexingTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#AnnotationTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#SearchTask\",\"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#QueryFormulationTask\"]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"ACTRIS\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Aerosol, Clouds and Trace Gases Research Infrastructure (ACTRIS)\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9f6feee0-a960-013c-1b52-000c2912e21a\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/9f6feee0-a960-013c-1b52-000c2912e21a\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.actris.eu\"}]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":15.0,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":271.75,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1075},"GEOSP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdf.geospecies.org/ont/geospecies"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"GEOSP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdf.geospecies.org/ont/geospecies#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The GeoSpecies Ontology is used to describe geographical distribution of living species.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Environment\"]","dct:title":"GeoSpecies Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOSP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-01-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-03-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=GEOSP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOSP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOSP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2012-10-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOSP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=GEOSP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOSP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOSP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOSP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov, https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://fairsharing.org]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":10.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdf.geospecies.org/ont/geospecies","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdf.geospecies.org/ont/geospecies"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://dbpedia.org/property/, http://www.geonames.org/ontology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://lod.taxonconcept.org/ontology/txn.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://rdf.geospecies.org/methods/observationMethod.rdf\"]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/event.owl\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.geonames.org/ontology\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.33,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://dbpedia.org/property/, http://www.geonames.org/ontology]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOSP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/event.owl\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.geonames.org/ontology\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://rdf.geospecies.org/methods/observationMethod.rdf\"]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://lod.taxonconcept.org/ontology/txn.owl]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.33,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"LOV Migration"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/LOV_migration\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Peter J. DeVries\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d8077f00-d1be-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d8077f00-d1be-013e-42aa-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"pdevries@wisc.edu\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOSP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-10-02"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":247.33,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1599},"BIOREGIONS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/biogeographic-regions2011/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/biogeographic-regions2011/view","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIOREGIONS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/biogeographic-regions2011/","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/elter_cl/10546\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The biogeographical regions dataset contains the official delineations used in the Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC) and for the EMERALD Network set up under the Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife and Natural Habitats (Bern Convention). The dataset is INSPIRE compliant. The vocabulary is used for 2016 and 2011 versions of the dataset.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Biogeographical regions\",\"Habitats Directive\"]","dct:title":"Biogeographical regions","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"biogeographic-regions2011","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"17"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-01-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2012-06-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/search?ontologies=BIOREGIONS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/ontologies/BIOREGIONS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080/search?ontologies=BIOREGIONS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://dd.eionet.europa.eu/, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://dd.eionet.europa.eu/, https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/biogeographic-regions2011/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/biodiversity/biogeographic-regions2011/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"http://vocabs.lter-europe.net/elter_cl/10546\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#glossary","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"European Environment Agency"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, name=LifeWatch Italy Data Portal, updated=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/OBOE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ENVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SBTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIODIVTHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/I-ADOPT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ELTER_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ECSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/TRAITS_THES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ALIENSPECIES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PCO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=LW ITA Data Portal, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/admin, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri], created=2024-10-08T10:13:34.000+00:00, homePage=https://data.lifewatchitaly.eu, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.ir, description=LifeWatch Italy data portal for the managing and sharing of biodiversity and ecosystem data. , institution=CNR, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/LW+ITA+Data+Portal, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, name=Italian Integrated Environmental Research Infrastructures System, updated=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CHEMFONT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CODATA-RDMT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/EUNIS_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FABIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_VARIABLES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/WISE_CLASS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SFWO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOVT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LITHOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/DCSO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INBIO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/CPMETA, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ERITHES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FAIR_VOCABULARY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INSTRUMENT, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/MARINETLO, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PALEO_PROXY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FIP_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ARCHIVE, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/INTERPRETATION, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/SNOWTERM, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_CL, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/N2000_HABITATS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEOLOGIC_UNITS, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/LIPD_ONTOLOGY, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/GEO_STRUCTURES, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/ACTRIS_VOCAB, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/BIOREGIONS], acronym=ITINERIS, creator=[https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/davideraho, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/irosati, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/alexandra.muresan, https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri], created=2024-10-14T13:26:20.000+00:00, homePage=https://itineris.cnr.it, contacts=ilaria.rosati@cnr.it, description=Most critical issues currently faced by our society involve key environmental challenges. Pollution, land use and climate change, and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem integrity need to be urgently addressed, providing quantitative knowledge to be transformed into actionable strategies.\r\n\r\nGiven the complexity of such challenges, a multi-disciplinary approach to the Earth System is deemed crucial. This approach involves combining field and laboratory measurements, analyses, experiments, data analysis, and modeling tools across the various interlinked environmental domains. Italy is actively involved in all major pan-European Environmental Research Infrastructures (RIs) and also hosts other nationally relevant RIs, all essential for providing the systematic and coherent information needed for high-level research. Given the large number and heterogeneity of these infrastructures, coordinated actions are essential to integrate and interlink them, as well as to harmonize their activities.\r\n\r\nTo achieve an integrated approach to the Earth system and its changes, the 22 participating RIs agreed to jointly prepare and build the thematic network called ITINERIS. The primary objective of ITINERIS is to establish the italian integrated system of the Research Infrastructures in the environmental scientific domain, facilitating observation and study of processes in the atmosphere, marine domain, terrestrial biosphere, and geosphere.\r\n\r\nSuch a broad-scale and long-term vision of environmental research, sustained by the main Italian scientists currently involved in European RIs, is truly innovative and it will support Italy in taking a leading role in European environmental research activities, designing the framework for the next decades., institution=National Research Council of Italy, @id=https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/projects/ITINERIS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":264.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":876},"NANOPUB_TRIG":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/np/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NANOPUB_TRIG","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/OTHER\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This is n example of a concatenate trig file from Nanodash.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Concatenate TriG","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANOPUB_TRIG/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"6"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-04-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-04-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=NANOPUB_TRIG&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANOPUB_TRIG/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANOPUB_TRIG/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANOPUB_TRIG/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=NANOPUB_TRIG&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANOPUB_TRIG/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANOPUB_TRIG/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANOPUB_TRIG","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"3"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/np/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/np/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANOPUB_TRIG/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/OTHER\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Martina Pulieri"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/NANOPUB_TRIG/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":207.0,"normalizedScore":43,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1171},"PECO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/peco"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/peco/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PECO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/peco#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This ontology defines a vocabulary for describing provenance traces of carbon emission calculations by capturing the quantifiable measurements of carbon emission sources used by some activities (e.g., electricity used by a machinery to produce a product, petrol used to make a car journey, etc.) and emission conversion factors used to estimate the carbon emissions produced by these. In addition, the ontology provides the ability to capture various data transformations that occurred before energy estimates may be used with relevant conversion factors. For example, sensors may provide raw readings about a water flow of an irrigation rig in an agri-food operation which is then used as a proxy to estimate the total volume of fertilisers used.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Environment\"]","dct:title":"The Provenance of Emission Calculations Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"13","omv:numberOfProperties":"8","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"peco","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PECO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"4"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-01-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"With the Net Zero agenda gaining significant traction across the world, organisations are often required to report carbon emissions associated with their operation. However, calculating emissions is a non-trivial task and reported scores can differ depending on the choices made by those performing the calculations or the software used to assist with this task. Emission conversion factors are used to calculate greenhouse emissions for different business operations. This ontology aims to enhance the transparency of the carbon footprint calculations via detailed provenance traces.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2023-04-23T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PECO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PECO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PECO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"3","dct:modified":"2023-05-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PECO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PECO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"9","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PECO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PECO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PECO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"9"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu, https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/peco","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/peco"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"https://qudt.org/2.1/schema/qudt/\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PECO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"https://qudt.org/2.1/schema/qudt/\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/peco/0.0.1","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"LOV Migration"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PECO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/peco/0.0.1","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":256.44,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1411},"FOS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[\"FOS 2007 has been developed in order to provide to all persons and organisations that may need to have a classification of the field of science and technology such a tool. The main target was the statistical institutes or organisations that may need to create statistics on the topic. This classification should be used for the R&D expenditure of the government, higher education and PNP (Private Non-Profit) sectors and if possible of the BE (Business enterprise) sector and for personnel data in all sectors.\"]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"FOS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/c_2a2fdea7","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[\"UNESCO and Eurostat both use this classification, as well as countries that have to deal with or provide information to them. Furthermore, United Nations\\u2019 UNstats has implemented FOS 2007 as well.\"]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This classification is the Eurostat standard code list for the classification of fields of science and technology (FOS 2007). The classification of field of science is based on the nomenclature suggested by UNESCO: Recommendation concerning the International Standardisation of Statistics on Science and Technology.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Field of science and technology classification","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"fos","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"51"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/c_d00d207a\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/c_3829ac45\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/c_bb9e4dae\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/c_e59d15bc\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/c_2a2fdea7\",\"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/c_7ab0431b\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2024-11-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-11-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=FOS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/ontologies/FOS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://ecoportal.lifewatchdev.eu:8443/search?ontologies=FOS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://kos.lifewatch.eu/thesauri/fos/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/eurostat/fos07/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#thesaurus","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/eurostat/fos07/","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Cristina Di Muri"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"0438wbg98\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:0438wbg98\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d83ae5c0-8d74-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/d83ae5c0-8d74-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"04h4z8k05\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:04h4z8k05\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"UNESCO\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/32664140-8d77-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/32664140-8d77-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/CristinaDiMuri\",\"notation\":\"033d3q980\",\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Identifiers/ROR:033d3q980\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Eurostat\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1cfae860-8d77-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/1cfae860-8d77-013d-e781-005056949ca7\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabulary/eurostat/fos07/view\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/FOS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"VocBench\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":13.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":52.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":261.75,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":380}},"combinedScores":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}],"properties":["owl:ontologyIRI"],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":1.87,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}],"properties":["dct:identifier"],"state":{"success":13,"average":2,"fail":71}},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":1.86,"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}],"properties":["owl:versionIRI"],"state":{"success":12,"average":13,"fail":61}}},"score":24.73,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":13.67,"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}],"properties":["omv:knownUsage","foaf:homepage","void:uriRegexPattern","omv:acronym","vann:preferredNamespaceUri","dct:subject","dct:coverage","dct:audience","foaf:page","doap:bugDatabase","skos:hiddenLabel","idot:exampleIdentifier","door:comesFromTheSameDomain","owl:backwardCompatibleWith","vann:example","mod:hasEvaluation","dct:alternative","doap:mailing-list","dct:description","omv:resourceLocator","omv:keywords","dct:title","dct:publisher","doap:repository"],"state":{"success":39,"average":47,"fail":0}},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.51,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}],"properties":["omv:numberOfClasses","omv:numberOfProperties","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix","mod:metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms","omv:numberOfIndividuals"],"state":{"success":46,"average":40,"fail":0}},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}],"properties":["dct:hasPart","omv:isOfType","omv:keyClasses","dct:dateSubmitted","dct:abstract","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children","dct:created","dct:bibliographicCitation","pav:curatedOn","foaf:depiction","void:openSearchDescription","schema:comment","void:propertyPartition","dct:valid","void:classPartition","mod:classesWithOneChild","dct:modified","void:dataDump","foaf:logo","void:uriLookupEndpoint","door:hasDisparateModelling","mod:classesWithNoDefinition","schema:associatedMedia","schema:workTranslation","voaf:usedBy","dct:language","mod:analytics","owl:incompatibleWith","void:rootResource","mod:browsingUI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith","schema:award","voaf:toDoList","mod:maxChildCount"],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":24.19,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":1.12,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}],"properties":["schema:includedInDataCatalog"],"state":{"success":12,"average":10,"fail":64}},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":1.14,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}],"properties":["schema:includedInDataCatalog"],"state":{"success":2,"average":20,"fail":64}},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}}},"score":2.26,"normalizedScore":9,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":72.17,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":2.51,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}],"properties":["owl:ontologyIRI","dct:identifier"],"state":{"success":36,"average":0,"fail":50}},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":16.67,"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}],"properties":["owl:ontologyIRI"],"state":{"success":10,"average":76,"fail":0}},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":1.6,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}],"properties":["sd:endpoint"],"state":{"success":23,"average":0,"fail":63}}},"score":27.79,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}],"state":{"success":86,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":3.79,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}],"properties":["owl:deprecated","omv:status"],"state":{"success":77,"average":9,"fail":0}}},"score":19.79,"normalizedScore":98,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":97.58,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":16.29,"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}],"properties":["omv:hasOntologyLanguage"],"state":{"success":42,"average":43,"fail":1}},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":9.88,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}],"properties":["omv:hasOntologyLanguage"],"state":{"success":85,"average":0,"fail":1}},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":3.84,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}],"properties":["omv:hasOntologySyntax"],"state":{"success":66,"average":0,"fail":20}},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":4.3,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}],"properties":["omv:hasFormalityLevel"],"state":{"success":74,"average":0,"fail":12}},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}],"properties":["dct:hasFormat","dct:isFormatOf"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}}},"score":34.31,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.7,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}],"properties":["owl:imports"],"state":{"success":12,"average":0,"fail":74}},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.64,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}],"properties":["dct:relation"],"state":{"success":11,"average":0,"fail":75}},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.64,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}],"properties":["voaf:hasEquivalencesWith"],"state":{"success":11,"average":0,"fail":75}},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.09,"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}],"properties":["schema:translationOfWork","voaf:generalizes","voaf:specializes","voaf:similar","dct:isPartOf"],"state":{"success":4,"average":0,"fail":82}},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":1.27,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}],"properties":["voaf:metadataVoc"],"state":{"success":0,"average":30,"fail":56}}},"score":3.34,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":6.85,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}],"properties":["dct:hasPart","owl:imports","mod:obsoleteProperty","mod:synonymProperty","omv:hasOntologySyntax","dct:isPartOf","door:comesFromTheSameDomain","mod:prefLabelProperty","dct:relation","dct:hasVersion","voaf:specializes","schema:translationOfWork","voaf:generalizes","door:hasDisparateModelling","mod:hierarchyProperty","owl:priorVersion","dct:subject","dct:isFormatOf","schema:workTranslation","voaf:usedBy","omv:hasFormalityLevel","dct:license","owl:backwardCompatibleWith","mod:definitionProperty","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith","owl:incompatibleWith","mod:authorProperty","dct:hasFormat","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith","voaf:similar"],"state":{"success":82,"average":4,"fail":0}}},"score":6.85,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":44.5,"normalizedScore":40,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":4.7,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}],"properties":["mod:definitionProperty","mod:prefLabelProperty","mod:authorProperty","mod:obsoleteProperty","mod:synonymProperty"],"state":{"success":78,"average":4,"fail":4}},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.16,"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}],"properties":["mod:obsoleteParent","mod:hierarchyProperty","mod:maxDepth"],"state":{"success":23,"average":63,"fail":0}},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}}},"score":6.86,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":13.6,"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}],"properties":["dct:license"],"state":{"success":78,"average":0,"fail":8}},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.07,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}],"properties":["dct:accessRights","cc:morePermissions"],"state":{"success":2,"average":84,"fail":0}},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.28,"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}],"properties":["cc:useGuidelines","dct:rightsHolder"],"state":{"success":3,"average":83,"fail":0}}},"score":24.95,"normalizedScore":67,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}],"properties":["schema:translator","dct:creator","dct:contributor","pav:curatedBy"],"state":{"success":0,"average":60,"fail":26}},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.23,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}],"properties":["prov:wasGeneratedBy","prov:wasInvalidatedBy","dct:source"],"state":{"success":0,"average":9,"fail":77}},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.12,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}],"properties":["dct:accrualPolicy","dct:accrualMethod","dct:accrualPeriodicity"],"state":{"success":0,"average":4,"fail":82}},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":3.49,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}],"properties":["dct:hasVersion","owl:priorVersion","owl:versionInfo"],"state":{"success":64,"average":22,"fail":0}},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.58,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}],"properties":["omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology"],"state":{"success":1,"average":18,"fail":67}},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.42,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}],"properties":["omv:designedForOntologyTask","mod:competencyQuestion"],"state":{"success":0,"average":18,"fail":68}},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.19,"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}],"properties":["foaf:fundedBy"],"state":{"success":8,"average":0,"fail":78}}},"score":8.02,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":2.5,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}],"properties":["mod:ontologyInUse","omv:endorsedBy"],"state":{"success":2,"average":39,"fail":45}},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}],"properties":["mod:group"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":86}},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":5.37,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}],"properties":["dct:accessRights"],"state":{"success":77,"average":0,"fail":9}}},"score":7.87,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.71,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":261.97,"minScore":202.0,"maxScore":309.0,"medianScore":265.125,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0},"status":{"request":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8082/fairness-assessment/?combined=true&ontologies=all&portal=ecoportal","success":true,"executionTime":106,"endpoint":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080","useCache":true}}