{"ontologies":{"PORO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/releases/2016-10-06/poro.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/obophenotype/porifera-ontology","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PORO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Species_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"Porifera (sponge) ontology\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":" An ontology describing the anatomical structures and characteristics of Porifera (sponges).","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/obophenotype/porifera-ontology/refs/heads/master/poro.owl","omv:keywords":"[\"phenotype\",\"trait\"]","dct:title":"Porifera Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"896","omv:numberOfProperties":"54","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#DomainOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-05-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"6","dct:created":"2014-07-19T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PORO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"153","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/search?ontologies=PORO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"162","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"39"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[https://bioportal.bioontology.org, https://ontobee.org, https://ebi.ac.uk/ols]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":12.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":89.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/cl_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/chebi_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/go_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/ro_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/pato_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/uberon_import.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/cl_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/chebi_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/go_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/ro_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/pato_import.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/poro/imports/uberon_import.owl]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/OWL_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Aquatic_Ecology\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/BIO\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Species_Diversity\",\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/categories/Functional_Diversity\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"http://w3id.org/nkos/nkostype#ontology","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"12"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Bob Thacker"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bob Thacker\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/32e55c90-1ec2-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/32e55c90-1ec2-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/users/martina_pulieri\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Chris Mungall\",\"affiliations\":[],\"id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/32feec00-1ec2-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@id\":\"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/Agents/32feec00-1ec2-013e-2d72-3c241174c172\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"affiliations\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#memberOf\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.ecoportal.lifewatch.eu/ontologies/PORO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":284.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1191}},"combinedScores":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}],"properties":["owl:ontologyIRI"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}],"properties":["dct:identifier"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}],"properties":["owl:versionIRI"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}],"properties":["omv:knownUsage","foaf:homepage","void:uriRegexPattern","omv:acronym","vann:preferredNamespaceUri","dct:subject","dct:coverage","dct:audience","foaf:page","doap:bugDatabase","skos:hiddenLabel","idot:exampleIdentifier","door:comesFromTheSameDomain","owl:backwardCompatibleWith","vann:example","mod:hasEvaluation","dct:alternative","doap:mailing-list","dct:description","omv:resourceLocator","omv:keywords","dct:title","dct:publisher","doap:repository"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}],"properties":["omv:numberOfClasses","omv:numberOfProperties","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix","mod:metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms","omv:numberOfIndividuals"],"state":{"success":0,"average":1,"fail":0}},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}],"properties":["dct:hasPart","omv:isOfType","omv:keyClasses","dct:dateSubmitted","dct:abstract","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children","dct:created","dct:bibliographicCitation","pav:curatedOn","foaf:depiction","void:openSearchDescription","schema:comment","void:propertyPartition","dct:valid","void:classPartition","mod:classesWithOneChild","dct:modified","void:dataDump","foaf:logo","void:uriLookupEndpoint","door:hasDisparateModelling","mod:classesWithNoDefinition","schema:associatedMedia","schema:workTranslation","voaf:usedBy","dct:language","mod:analytics","owl:incompatibleWith","void:rootResource","mod:browsingUI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith","schema:award","voaf:toDoList","mod:maxChildCount"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":6.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}],"properties":["schema:includedInDataCatalog"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":6.0,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}],"properties":["schema:includedInDataCatalog"],"state":{"success":0,"average":1,"fail":0}},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}}},"score":12.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":89.0,"normalizedScore":78,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}],"properties":["owl:ontologyIRI","dct:identifier"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}],"properties":["owl:ontologyIRI"],"state":{"success":0,"average":1,"fail":0}},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}],"properties":["sd:endpoint"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}],"properties":["owl:deprecated","omv:status"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}],"properties":["omv:hasOntologyLanguage"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}],"properties":["omv:hasOntologyLanguage"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}],"properties":["omv:hasOntologySyntax"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}],"properties":["omv:hasFormalityLevel"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}],"properties":["dct:hasFormat","dct:isFormatOf"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}],"properties":["owl:imports"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}],"properties":["dct:relation"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}],"properties":["voaf:hasEquivalencesWith"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}],"properties":["schema:translationOfWork","voaf:generalizes","voaf:specializes","voaf:similar","dct:isPartOf"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}],"properties":["voaf:metadataVoc"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}],"properties":["dct:hasPart","owl:imports","mod:obsoleteProperty","mod:synonymProperty","omv:hasOntologySyntax","dct:isPartOf","door:comesFromTheSameDomain","mod:prefLabelProperty","dct:relation","dct:hasVersion","voaf:specializes","schema:translationOfWork","voaf:generalizes","door:hasDisparateModelling","mod:hierarchyProperty","owl:priorVersion","dct:subject","dct:isFormatOf","schema:workTranslation","voaf:usedBy","omv:hasFormalityLevel","dct:license","owl:backwardCompatibleWith","mod:definitionProperty","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith","owl:incompatibleWith","mod:authorProperty","dct:hasFormat","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith","voaf:similar"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}],"properties":["mod:definitionProperty","mod:prefLabelProperty","mod:authorProperty","mod:obsoleteProperty","mod:synonymProperty"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}],"properties":["mod:obsoleteParent","mod:hierarchyProperty","mod:maxDepth"],"state":{"success":0,"average":1,"fail":0}},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}],"properties":["dct:license"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}],"properties":["dct:accessRights","cc:morePermissions"],"state":{"success":0,"average":1,"fail":0}},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}],"properties":["cc:useGuidelines","dct:rightsHolder"],"state":{"success":0,"average":1,"fail":0}}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}],"properties":["schema:translator","dct:creator","dct:contributor","pav:curatedBy"],"state":{"success":0,"average":1,"fail":0}},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}],"properties":["prov:wasGeneratedBy","prov:wasInvalidatedBy","dct:source"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}],"properties":["dct:accrualPolicy","dct:accrualMethod","dct:accrualPeriodicity"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}],"properties":["dct:hasVersion","owl:priorVersion","owl:versionInfo"],"state":{"success":0,"average":1,"fail":0}},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}],"properties":["omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}],"properties":["omv:designedForOntologyTask","mod:competencyQuestion"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}],"properties":["foaf:fundedBy"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}],"properties":["mod:ontologyInUse","omv:endorsedBy"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}],"properties":["mod:group"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}],"properties":["dct:accessRights"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":284.0,"minScore":284.0,"maxScore":284.0,"medianScore":284.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":478.0},"status":{"request":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8082/fairness-assessment/?combined=true&ontologies=PORO&portal=ecoportal","success":true,"executionTime":149,"endpoint":"http://ecoportal.lifewatch.eu:8080","useCache":true}}